Hi, I've been lurking for a while among everyone's various trials and tribulations.
Here's my story: I attended and excelled at research-institution State U, and, after 3 years of life in the wide world of work, applied to top programs (as informed by the US News & World Report as well as by various English profs at my BA institution) in English for my Ph.D. hoping to have a shot at a research career someday. I've only been admitted to one school at this point (IU-Bloomington, guaranteed on-the-dole), waiting on 2.
Like most of you I want a research career eventually so (perhaps naively) I'm still hurting from no top-10 admission, and neither I nor my partner (a chemist who's madly looking for work in Indianapolis) want to move to the boonies. However, unlike the other schools I applied to in quest of the 'right' Ph.D., Indiana actually has people in my area of interest (Gothic, Victorian, and contemporary combinations of both), plus their job placement rates are good. But after a month of thinking I'd be OK with even a back-up school, I have cold feet. Besides the terrors no-more-big-paycheque and living-in-a-village, I'm scared that this good-but-not-awesome Ph.D. won't help me get where I want to go.
Am I being utterly ridiculous? Are any of you in a similar situation? If so, what are you thinking?