Just wanted to let you know you're not in the boat alone -- I'm going to follow this thread closely and see if anyone offers some advice that tips either of us in one direction. Very best of luck!!
1. A top #100 university with a fabulous research match and surprisingly, advisor comes recently from #2 Education school in country. (Don't know why he's now at this school.) Full funding.
2. The #1 ranked department, good research match, friendly professors. Also, my first acceptance -- feels like my "first love." Full funding.
3. Third, Ivy League, fabulous research match, highly respected but fairly aloof faculty, . Much less funding, but holy crap, never even thought I had a chance.
I'm dying here. (Wonderful problem to have, tho.)
Accepted: Columbia, U-Wisc Madison, Illinois-Chicago
Rejected: Northwestern, U-Chicago
Waiting: none