Let me frame the situation. Over 2 years ago, I applied to PhD programs in Literature and was summarily rejected to all of them, save a few offers for masters programs--including the hotly debated MAPH program at Chicago and an interdisciplinary MA at NYU. I may have been a little too foolhardy in my belief that I would get even one PhD offer, but I felt that I was at least competitive at some of the programs: a 3.95 undergrad GPA, middle 90's percentile on my GRE verbal, some publications, 2 years of ESL tutoring experience, lots volunteer experience and (I thought) a focused interest for grad studies. With stinging pride and increased wisdom, I decided to hold off and reevaluate my prospects.
2 years later, I find myself reapplying to programs. My hiatus has given me 2 full years of experience as a speech writer for the Director of a DOE laboratory, as well as a year of Adjunct teaching experience at the college level, but still, this time around I am cautiously aiming at both MA programs at what you could call "2nd tier" schools (state schools, well known but not Ivy-caliber private institutions), as well as a few MA and PhD programs at some bigger schools. My ultimate goal is the PhD, without question, but for the time being, I am convincing myself that there is wisdom in first pursuing a Master's degree, doing well, and then re-applying to the "Upper Tier" schools. I have made the assumptions that:
1) Having a Master's degree will show PhD programs that I can perform beyond the BA
2) The process of earning a Master's degree will help me find depth in certain areas, and allow me to stem some of my generalist tendencies
3) Earning the MA will afford me increased teaching experience
4) I will subsequently gain stronger letters of recommendation and a more focused statement of purpose
The drawbacks to this route are obviously the time of earning a discrete MA and THEN a PhD, and the cost of earning 2 individual degrees.
I guess my reason for posting this topic is to garner reassurance from some of you salty and salted grad students--reassurance that this route (BA at one school, unique MA program, PhD program) can yield its own benefits. Am I deluding myself? Have any of you followed this course (I think I read that Minnesotan is doing this)? Do my assumptions hold any water? Help me objectively see the realities of this course of progress.
Concerning my situation, there are quite a few subtleties that I didn't care to address for the sake of space, but I would value any opinion based on what you know. Regards...