Hi folks! I thought I could reply to this thread too....but I tweaked the original format to reflect my slightly different track.
BA Institution: Ivy League
Major(s): History
Minor(s): Asian/Middle Eastern Studies
GPA in Major: 3.63
Overall GPA: 3.68
Position in Class: Third (lowest) Honor Group
MA Institution: In New York
Major(s): History
Minor(s): N/A
GPA in Major: 4.00
Overall GPA: 4.00
Doctor of Arts Institution: In New York
Major(s): History
Minor(s): N/A
GPA in Major: 4.00
Overall GPA: 4.00
Position in Department: N/A
Type of Student: Asian
GRE Q: 760 (84%)
GRE V: 660 (94%)
GRE W: 5 (87%)
Research Experience: Presidential Scholars Research Assistantship (Undergraduate), MA Thesis Publication Pending on seventh-century Korean history (2012)
Awards/Honors/Other Recognition: Church Scholarship (2010), Doctoral Fellowship (2010-2011)
Pertinent Activities or Jobs: See above
Any Miscellaneous Accomplishments that Might Help: Sunday School Teacher at my church (2009-present), interning teacher at my after school academy (2003-present)
Languages: English (native), French (proficient), Korean (weakly proficient)
Special Bonus Points: Rare field (Transnational Jesuit Missionary Activity among Korean exiles/natives, 1550-1750)
Applying to Where: PhD History Rejected: 6 (Columbia, CUNY Graduate Center, U Nebraska-Lincoln, U Hawaii at Manoa, Indiana U); PhD History Decision Pending: 6 (U Iowa, Notre Dame, Catholic University of America, NYU, SUNY Stony Brook, SUNY Binghamton)
Letters of Recommendation: Specialists in African, Mongolian, Ancient, Classical, Medieval, Early Modern English, and American history
Statement of Purpose: The two biggest themes of my SOP lay in my emphasis on how much mentors have taught me and the many ways with which one could study my proposed field.
Writing Sample: A 25-page-paper related to my field
Communication with POI: A few professors told me about some members who might take an interest in my field, but this interest has not translated into an admission offer.
Lessons Learned from Application Process: As I suspected, the History PhD applications process counts as highly selective. I definitely consider it a roulette game that almost depends (almost) solely on luck.