This is sort of ridiculous since I should really be out celebrating and not second-guessing everything etc., but here it goes. Suddenly I am left wondering whether I should have aimed a little higher with regard to where I was applying. I graduated from a top 25 research university for undergrad, magna cum laude etc. Had around a 1300 on the GREs, no amazing LORs, no publications etc. The PhD programs I applied to were mostly around the 30 mark in the rankings. I am excited about these programs but am wondering if, given the difficulty of job placement etc. (we all know the pitfalls of academia, despite the fact that it would be nice if rankings didn't matter), I might have tried for some of the higher-ranked programs. At what point does this no longer really mean anything? In other words, I'm not talking about Princeton and Stanford here. Does the difference between, say, OSU and Rutgers really matter? Thank you all for your responses.