Hello,
I am in a similar situation. I was accepted to Tyler's MFA program for painting and went to an interview at SAIC, where they recommended me for their post-bac program. I am having trouble deciding because I already have my BFA and one residency experience at The Vermont Studio Center. Usually, post-bac programs are for students with only ba/less academic art experience.
So, I know that Tyler's program is much more affordable, but I loved the students and faculty I meet at SAIC. I feel that it is possible that the post-bac program could lead to bigger and better things, but it is just such a large financial setback. I am torn 50/50! Anybody have advice?