suncertainty Posted June 25 Posted June 25 Hello, I've previously posted a similar thread in December 2023. With my junior year finished, and looking to apply this fall, I want to get a final review of my profile and my school list. Undergrad Institution: USNews Top 50 Major(s): Mathematics Minor(s): Data Science GPA: 3.98/4.00 (Major GPA 4.0) Type of Student: Domestic Asian Male GRE General Test: Taking it soon GRE Subject Test: No plan to take it TOEFL Score: N/A Grad Institution: None Current Research Interests: All past works have been ML related, but I'm also interested in methodological and theoretical aspects of statistics/biostatistics. Research Experience: Funded summer research experience at my home institution (worked with a stats professor on building regression model for aerospace engineering problem, no pubs) Funded year-long research in interdisciplinary conservation ecology project (building object detection network) Likely result in second-author paper in non-statistics journal, but not sure if it will be done prior application deadlines Recently joined another research project that will likely last for a semester Other Activities or Jobs: Undergraduate TA for the following courses: two semesters of Intro to Data Science, one semester of Probability (proof-based) Undergraduate TA for mathematical statistics Math/Statistics Grades: (T - transfer credit (AP Exam), P - pass/fail) Math/Statistics: Elementary Statistics (T) Calc I (T) Calc II (T) Multivariable Calculus (A) Linear Algebra (A) Foundations of Math (P) -> pass/fail during covid, i hope i can remedy this with my real analysis grade Probability and Statistics for Scientists (A) Regression Analysis (A) Probability Theory (A) Mathematical Statistics (A) Survival Analysis (A) Real Analysis I (A) - epsilon-delta stuff Real Analysis II (A) - intro. to measure theory (covered up to dominated convergence theorem) Data Science: Intro Data Science (A) Intro CS (A) Databases (A) Data Visualization (A) Applied Machine Learning (A) Applied Data Analytics in R (A) Plan to take: Complex Analysis Abstract Algebra or Advanced Linear Algebra Statistical Learning Bioinformatics Programs Applying: Primarily biostatistics PhDs. My dream is to get into one of the top 10 schools in usnews, but I'm applying also those outside of top 10. Letters of Recommendation: - One from an assistant professor who mentored me for the first two research experience listed above -> can speak about research ability - One from another assistant professor who mentored me for the third research experience and survival analysis -> can speak about research ability + some biostatistics - One from a pure math professor (tenured) who taught measure theory and will be teaching complex analysis -> can speak about mathematical maturity - One from a statistics professor (tenured) who taught probability theory and mathematical statistics -> can speak about ability to do probability/statistics Here are my potential lists, and I have some worries. My plan is to apply to many reach schools and hope to get in at least one. If not, I will first pursue a masters degree (hopefully some PhD programs I apply will consider me for masters). Biostatistics PhD: Harvard University Johns Hopkins University UNC Chapel Hill Brown University Yale University University of Washington University of Michigan Columbia University Duke University University of Pennsylvania UC Berkeley University of Minnesota — Twin Cities Vanderbilt University Emory University Statistics PhD: University of Michigan NC State Masters: Stanford University (MS Statistics) University of Pennsylvania (MSE in Data Science) Harvard University (MS Biostatistics) University of Chicago (MS Statistics) + Some PhD schools listed above that might consider me for masters. Here are some of my questions: Q: I know most schools require 3 letters, and I'm having a hard to between choosing from the four. Any advice on how to choose rec writers? Q: I know there are lots of schools up there, and I wish to cut few out if possible. Am I reaching too high, or is this reasonable. Any recommended schools to add/remove? Q: I have the choice to take either a second course in linear algebra or first course of abstract algebra. Would taking the second linear algebra course make my transcript look nicer? Q: I'm mostly concerned that my researches and background may not suit biostatistics programs (besides I've taken survival analysis and will be taking bioinformatics soon). Would I be better off applying to traditional stats programs? Thank you so much in advance and any advice/comments will be appreciated! alemao 1
bayessays Posted June 27 Posted June 27 1. I'd definitely choose the research people, and then whichever of the last two knows you best/will write a positive letter that shows you'll be successful - your grades are so good that I don't think you really need to prove to people you can do the math. 2. I don't think you're reaching too high at all. I don't think you need to apply to MS programs, though - as you said, you'll be considered automatically at most places. I think you can do better than Duke/Emory/Vanderbilt/Yale. Admissions are still competitive, so I don't feel comfortable saying these are safeties at all, but I think you can get into some better programs. 3. Take more linear algebra, no question. 4. No, your background is ideal for biostatistics. But I do sort of wonder why you are so focused on biostatistics, as you don't mention any particular research interests. If you want to have more options, I'd replace some biostat schools and think about applying to a couple schools in the USNews 20s like UIUC/Ohio State/Texas. suncertainty and alemao 2
suncertainty Posted June 28 Author Posted June 28 Hi @bayessays Would you say I still get the letter from research person if they're new faculty (taught for 1~2 years now)? Also, I just had my GRE unofficial score of 167Q/158V. Do you think it's worth retaking for the sake of quant or just sticking with it. Thank you so much for the advice!!
alemao Posted June 28 Posted June 28 19 hours ago, bayessays said: 1. I'd definitely choose the research people, and then whichever of the last two knows you best/will write a positive letter that shows you'll be successful - your grades are so good that I don't think you really need to prove to people you can do the math. 2. I don't think you're reaching too high at all. I don't think you need to apply to MS programs, though - as you said, you'll be considered automatically at most places. I think you can do better than Duke/Emory/Vanderbilt/Yale. Admissions are still competitive, so I don't feel comfortable saying these are safeties at all, but I think you can get into some better programs. 3. Take more linear algebra, no question. 4. No, your background is ideal for biostatistics. But I do sort of wonder why you are so focused on biostatistics, as you don't mention any particular research interests. If you want to have more options, I'd replace some biostat schools and think about applying to a couple schools in the USNews 20s like UIUC/Ohio State/Texas. Hello @bayessays. On top of the question 3, if a person already has a master's in Statistics but lacks real analysis (and/or bad grades in linear algebra), would it be better to take those courses in a graduate level before applying to the PhD, or taking at an undergraduate level would be enough?
bayessays Posted June 28 Posted June 28 3 hours ago, suncertainty said: Hi @bayessays Would you say I still get the letter from research person if they're new faculty (taught for 1~2 years now)? Also, I just had my GRE unofficial score of 167Q/158V. Do you think it's worth retaking for the sake of quant or just sticking with it. Thank you so much for the advice!! Yes, I don't think seniority matters at all if they have a PhD (unless the alternative is like a famous statistician or something). Your GRE is fine, I would personally not retake it. IMO, anything 167-170 is almost the same. suncertainty 1
bayessays Posted June 28 Posted June 28 3 hours ago, alemao said: Hello @bayessays. On top of the question 3, if a person already has a master's in Statistics but lacks real analysis (and/or bad grades in linear algebra), would it be better to take those courses in a graduate level before applying to the PhD, or taking at an undergraduate level would be enough? The material you need to know is undergraduate real analysis and linear algebra, so I would not take graduate classes. Graduate classes are also grade-inflated so much that they won't help you as much. In your situation, I would probably just take undergrad real analysis and try to get an A. alemao 1
alemao Posted June 28 Posted June 28 3 minutes ago, bayessays said: The material you need to know is undergraduate real analysis and linear algebra, so I would not take graduate classes. Graduate classes are also grade-inflated so much that they won't help you as much. In your situation, I would probably just take undergrad real analysis and try to get an A. Thanks for always replying!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now