tragicomix Posted April 11, 2011 Share Posted April 11, 2011 This story starts with me getting an accept at a certain school where I was really interested in working with Prof. X. As soon as I got the accept, I e-mailed Prof. X asking him if he'd be taking on students and whether he'd be willing to consider advising me. I didn't get a reply for two weeks. After this I sent him a reminder upon which he replied saying that he was happy to hear I was admitted, and he was anticipating taking on some students. However, he said he doesn't commit to advising any students before meeting them in person. In the meantime I was contacted by Prof. Y who showed a lot of interested in advising me. Now, my preferences at this university are Prof. X, followed by Prof. Z followed by Prof. Y. I really like Prof. Z's work but I was missing some background. So, I contacted Prof. Z to know if that was gonna be a problem. He replied saying that it wasn't a problem at all. Since it seemed like I had a shot at working with Prof. X, and if that didn't work out, I also had reasonable "backup plans" in Prof. Z and Prof. Y, and this is a really great university and they made me a fantastic funding offer, I accepted. Since Prof. Y had called me and answered a lot of general questions I had about the program, I let him know that I was accepting the offer. He replied saying he was really happy to hear this and now introduced a new actor, Prof. U to the e-mail thread! So a quick summary of the situation is like this, ordered by my interest in these professors: Prof. X - has told me he doesn't commit to anyone before meeting them.Prof. Z - I don't have the perfect background for his work, but he seems positive.Prof. Y - I'm somewhat interested in his work, but he seems really interested in me.Prof. U - Not sure where he entered the picture from, because I don't really have the background for his work and am not that interested in it either. My question is, should I now contact Prof. X and ask him how I should prepare for the start of grad school this Fall? I want to do this for two reasons - (1) to show that I'm really interested in working with him and (2) do whatever preparatory work he suggests so that I can maximize my chance of working with him. Is this a good idea or does it come off sounding desperate? Any other suggestions on how I can maximize my chances of working with Prof. X or Prof. Z without getting into a situation where I commit to working with Prof. Z (thereby precluding any chance of working with Prof. X)? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now