Wise words from a student reader on a top-tier adcom

[doobiebrothers]

my best friend works on the adcom of probably the #1 religion/theology PhD program as a student reader (he's sitting here next to me deciding fates as we speak) and here is his incredibly wise advice:

1. Professors are suspicious of a perfect 4.0, because it shows an unwillingness to take risks. However, under a 3.5 and you also might be in trouble. On the bright side, GRE's really come into play with a lower GPA. Anything in the 3.9-3.6 range is generally fine, given all other parts are ok.

2. THE STATEMENT OF PURPOSE IS THE #1 most important thing. I can't emphasize that enough. 

3. WHO your letter writers are really matters, esp to the top programs. If someone on the committee knows professor XYZ, it helps so so much. At the top levels, it really is an insider game. Do you, personally know the profs on the committee? Do your profs know them? Work the nepotism as best you can. Network, visit the schools, get to know the decision makers. It makes a big difference.

4. Languages. Languages. Languages. In something like Hebrew Bible or Islamic studies, really get those Semitics down, do research in those languages, and demonstrate a good reading proficiency in German and French. One or two more can't hurt. 

 

And in the end, if all else fails, don't hesitate to re-apply! 

 

That's some good advice, and you're getting it straight from the horse's mouth. (and he's a very handsome horse  )