Jump to content

moderatedbliss

Members
  • Posts

    73
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by moderatedbliss

  1. Hello,

    The question I am about to ask is relevant to UK schools, but the general theme is applicable I'm sure.

    I received an offer for an MA in Modern Literature and Culture at the University of Birmingham (UK), with full tuition covered and a little bit of living expenses.

    I received an offer for Comparative and General literature at University of Edinburgh, and I would only have about 1/3 of tuition covered counting the small scholarship I got from an organization here in the States.

    I'm far more interested in Comparative Literature than I am in Anglo Modern Literature. I'm not sure if I want to continue on to a PhD afterwards. I would take the funded offer if I were sure I did not want to do a PhD afterwards, but I'm afraid that doing Modern Lit as opposed to comp lit is going to really hurt me. I'm also afraid that if I DON'T pursue academia, going to Birmingham will hurt me because Edinburgh is much more well known and highly regarded in the US.

    Literally any input you have would help me, its getting sort of down to the wire here (the UK system is different) and I'm quite stressed! 

    (:

  2. Eugh!

     

    I would interpret this as 'what made you go into your particular specialty,' but it's anybody's guess. Is this a scholarship for people staying within the university? For people who are applying elsewhere for graduate study starting fall '14? If they assume you're going elsewhere for your PhD, you can include some comments about your fit with the school of your choice, maybe, but I personally think the emphasis is on discipline. 

     

    Good luck.

    This is for graduate study at a new institution (new for me) 

    Ahhh why don't people reread their questions? In any case, I really appreciate your input. Vexed  :wacko:

  3. I applied for it in Archaeology - I've been accepted by the University and just did an interview for the scholarship. Has anyone else heard anything yet? Have you, moderatedbliss?

    Nope. I haven't even been accepted yet, and that's a big if. Somebody over on thestudentroom was interviewed as well, for history I believe. Waiting to hear back from the MML... it's killing me. 

  4. Hey, I've been waiting to hear back from Oxford, and I've been admitted to a number of different UK universities... I'll try to help where I can. 

    From what I've seen on the results page, specific departments were told that funding information would come on a later date. For the Clarendon they automatically consider you, I would check back on the Clarendon page frequently. Did you apply for the Ertegun? I saw that somebody was already notified for an Ertegun interview, so they may already be in the process of notifying people. 
    I was admitted to Cambridge, and thy said that funding decisions would be made by the end of April, and if I didn't hear back before then, I would assume that my application was unsuccessful. 
    Sorry if that wasn't very helpful, I suppose it seems like it's department specific. 

    As for your second question, I'm really not sure. I guess it relates to my answer for your third question.

    As for the third part: Let's say you opted for College A, but they found you were eligible for a scholarship in College B, this would mean that they would override your decision for College A in order to give you funding associated with College B, unless you specifically designated that you didn't want them to do that on your app. As you left it blank, I would imagine you'll get matched with any possible funding they would have for you. 

    Sorry I couldn't be more specific! 

  5. This isn't so much about ranking as it is about department culture in a way, but I definitely see what you're getting at.  I have always felt that if you are the smartest person in the room, you are in the wrong room.  It may be an adjustment if you are not used to being challenged, but I think people that genuinely enjoy learning thrive in environments where the material is challenging and you have the opportunity to learn from not only your professors, but also your peers.

    You may need some time to adjust to being challenged, but I think if you're aware that challenges will come and you're open to taking them as a learning experience and not as a blow to your ego, you will be great.  Be excited!  You might look like a fool, but so does everyone at some point.  Your peers face the same risk.  Learning is hard, and that's why it's so damn rewarding.  Just anticipate the challenges/struggles, don't take them personally (easier said than done, I know), and do your best.  You will grow so much more when you are being pushed!  I think you'll do very well.

    Sorry for the double post- I like that saying about being in the wrong room. I enjoyed being pampered, but I'm tired of being the only person in any my classes that's actually interested in the subject matter -- not a commentary on intelligence whatsoever, I just care more... 

    You bring up a good point about department culture as well; or the wider cultural in general. I'll be heading overseas, I don't know if I can deal with the traditionalism of some of the UK universities. I grew up in California, the idea of wearing robes aka "academic dress" seems absurd. Tradition for tradition's sake is moot, I say. MOOT. 

  6. i am in a similar situation to you, moderatedbliss - I went to a small, not very well-known or high-ranked private liberal arts college and will now be going to a top-ranked research university for my grad degree. For me, I'm much more in awe/worried that I am going to look stupid in a group of people who mostly attended more prestigious institutions for undergrad and are used to a more competitive environment. At my college I felt like I knew where I stood and when my work was good enough, but now I am a bit afraid that I will land in a group of people who are somehow much better than me and i won't be able to complete with them. Makes me a bit afraid to open my mouth! I know this is probably a silly thing to be worrying about, and I'm sure I'll feel better once I know where I stand after spending some time with the other grad students in my cohort. Right now I worry about being the DUMBEST person in the room and thus finding out that it's the wrong room :P

    I completely empathize with you. I noticed you applied to multiple California schools, did you go do your undergrad in Cali?

    I'm afraid of answering the dreaded, "So where did you do your undergrad?" question, and getting an "Oh, that's interesting!" Which is secretly code for, "Wow, why are you here?"

     

  7. I'm interested in how people that went to a relatively low-ranking undergraduate school fare when facing a massive prestige/"ranking" boost of their university in graduate school. 

    This is entirely subjective and based on speculation, so feel free to correct me. I attend a state school, and in both of my majors I've been treated like I'm the best thing since sliced bread. I feel like most people at my university are just there to get a degree and move on (which I can't fault them for) but I'm usually one of only a few people in my classes who is genuinely interested in learning and always participates (yeah, I'm THAT guy). My basic question is: if you're at a significantly lower ranking school than where you get accepted for graduate work, what is the transition like from being a star in your undergrad program to being adored in your undergrad program to being just another student in a more academically intense environment? Basically, what is it like no longer being considered the smartest person in the room? Is it liberating being with kindred spirits, or is is no longer being considered especially intelligent or special stressful and alienating? I feel like I haven't really been challenged during my undergraduate career, and frankly I'm afraid that I'm going to look like a fool. I suppose it's a bit of imposter syndrome. 

    Does anybody have any thoughts on this? 

  8. Received an offer at Cambridge for an MPhil in European/Comparative Literature and Cultures, waiting to hear back about an MSt in Comparative Lit at Oxford as part of the dept. of MML... "late March"

    Did anybody apply for an MML program at Oxford?!

    edit: also, if anybody hears back about either the clarendon or ertegun, make sure to mention it!

  9. I am going to pursue a PhD at Cambridge starting this October. I will be at Christ's College :) My PhD is based at the Sanger Institute and the PhD is funded by the Wellcome Trust. I will be studying parasite genomics :)

     

    Anybody else attending Cambridge?

    Congrats on getting in and getting funding!

    I was accepted for an MPhil, although I'm not sure if I'll attend. Still waiting to be placed in a college, my first and second choices were Wolfson College and St. Edmunds College. 

  10. I was accepted to sixteen schools. My top choices were Edinburgh and York. Both schools offered me half tuition (which is pretty good for a Master’s program over there), but it wasn’t NEARLY enough to cover the expenses I needed to before I could obtain a visa.

     

    The good news is, though, that they do better funding for their PhD programs. 

    Just curious, what program was this that they offered you half tuition for? I've seen no such offers anywhere for Comp Lit. 

  11. Hmm, that's useful. I didn't know there wasn't a comparative literature department/ undergrads couldn't major in comparative literature. From the looks of the faculty, they come from a multitude of departments. As long there are professors that have relevant interests, I suppose I should be okay. What was your experience in lit; from what I hear Edinburgh is well known for literature..

  12. Ditto - I'd like to know as well! Which award did you apply to?

    I applied to the "open" one for postgraduate study in the UK, hopefully that's specific enough.. I should have applied in partnership with a university, but I was afraid I wouldn't get in/ would be better suited somewhere I didn't apply in direct partnership for 

  13. I was accepted to several schools for my MA in the UK and desperately wanted to go. What held me back, however, was money. Even with the scholarships I was offered, I would have still had to come up with a ton of money to live on before the UK would grant me a student visa.

     

    I’m sure there are ways of doing it. I just felt hopeless and gave up. 

     

    That being said, however, I’ve regretted it ever since. I say if it’s your dream, you should go for it. 

    /: 

    Money is definitely an issue as well, but I don't want to regret not going. 

    What universities did you want to attend? 

  14. So far, I've been admitted to University of Edinburgh and University College London  for an MA in comparative literature. I'm not sure if I want to continue on to a PhD, which is why I'm opting for an MA instead of applying to a PhD directly. I did a fair bit of research on the programs, but I'm not really familiar with with the reputation of the specific comparative literature departments. In any case, I need help deciding which to attend! ANY criteria at all (finances, etc) is relevant in making my choice, nothing you say is irrelevant. 

    Broadly, my literary interests focus on magical realism in Southern America, German-language writers (primarily Sebald and the Austrian Bernhard) and the French concept of the Flaneur. 


    If one university may be a better idea for continuing on to a PhD and the other may be better in terms of the general job market, feel free to comment on that as well. 


    Edinburgh pros - 
    -Very small program size (I suppose this could also be a bad thing)
    -No formal language requirement, which means I could focus on the language I want to learn rather than improving the language I already know
    -Known for (English) literature
    -(Arguably) better international reputation than the other two? 
    Beautiful city, less expensive and less overwhelming than London
    -Tuition is less
    -More scholarship options

    UCL
    -Bigger program, probably better developed
    -Access to more networking because of both the bigger program and having access to the London Comparative Lit association 
    -Higher ranked overall
    -Professors that have relevant interests 

  15. Apologies for the double post:   Does anybody know if applicants for the postgraduate student award will be notified if they're on the shortlist? Or rather, will they randomly receive a phone call for an interview...? It would be nice to at least know that I got formally rejected. 

    I've been looking forward to this January 31st date for a while now, but from the sounds of things I'm not sure if I'll be hearing back at all..

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use