Just got in contact with her. She said the graduate school uses GRE scores (probably to determine funding), but such scores don't work the same way in the English department--they simply admit the "top 10-12" out of roughly 100 applicants. To me, that's basically the "test scores are one component, but we look at the application in its entirity; a low score does not necessarily bar one from admission, just as a stratospheric score does not ensure admission." That statement, and those similar, are already becoming all too common.... (!) That said, I don't think my verbal score is horrible, although it could certainly be higher. It's right on the edge of being "good," so I'm ambivalent over whether or not I should re-take the GRE. I would just like to know at what point GRE scores and GPAs are "cut off" and departments/graduate schools are no longer influenced by higher levels of distinction.