To all the international students! Don't give up! Despite a quite disadvantaged background (international, unknown school, different major), mediocre GRE scores and not perfect GPA, I managed to get into some of the top schools.
PROFILE:
Type of Undergrad Institution: non-ranked school in Latin America
Major: BA in Social Psychology
Undergrad GPA: 3.9
Type of Grad: mid-ranked school in Europe
Major: MA in International Relations Grad GPA: 3.5
GRE: 155V, 165Q, 3.0AW (AW is really embarrassing)
Any Special Courses: summer course (funded) at a top US school (during MA)
Letters of Recommendation: adviser from the grad school (non-polisci) + two star US profs from top schools (polisci)
Research Experience: 2 years of research assistance at the undergrad school + 1 year of research assistance at a well-known European research institute + several completed research projects + one mediocre non-polisci publication (peer-reviewed) + >10 conference presentations
Teaching Experience: One seminar
Subfield/Research Interests: Methodology, Comparative
Other: laureate of several national merit scholarships
RESULTS:
Acceptances($$ or no $$): Yale $$, Rochester $$
Waitlists: NYU, Princeton
Rejections: all others (overall I applied to 15 top schools) Going to: ?
LESSONS LEARNED:
It is very important for international students to receive good Quant GRE scores and get LORs from decent American profs (you can get to know them at conferences/summer schools/etc.)
Great SOP, Research experience and LORs could save you almost no matter what
But still you should spend more time on GRE
Additionally, I wish I could spend more time on customizing my SOP for all the departments and prospective advisers. Fit really matters.
Grade degradation (BA - 3.8, MA - 3.5) and change in major are no good
Applying to as many departments as possible really helps (of course, if you feel like you have at least a slight chance to get in)