Hi 3stars -- You're smart to put funding high on your list of important criteria. I'm not so sure I did that the first time around, and it really came back to haunt me! I'm hoping this application season I may have some options that are more realistic.
I had a mixed experience with Indiana, to be honest. The campus culture and other students, faculty, prospectives were really friendly and inviting, but the outreach weekend and the admissions/assistantships application process was disorganized. I felt that they didn't do a great job being pro-active at giving prospective students information. Anytime I needed something, I had to constantly initiate contact, and follow up, and hound them about getting back to me. The cohort was also really huge, so it felt pretty impersonal at times. It may have been that I was expecting so much from such a highly ranked school. Their funding packages are also a grab bag -- some didn't even include tuition remission, and many required you to commute to Indianapolis for the assistantship. It still seemed like a solid university, so that's why I kept it on my list this time around.
Michigan girl -- I've looked at some of those programs for a while, and am in the process of applying to UVA's program. As far as the others, George Mason I eliminated because of location, which I know may sound a bit absurd. However, I know the area pretty well, and I don't think it would be a good fit for me. Old Dominion's academics weren't quite what I was looking for, as the prospect of a doctoral degree is still something I may be interested in. (I think their entrance undergrad GPA was 2.5, and I'm well above that.) I'm on the fence about Virginia Tech, as I've heard good things but am still waffling a bit on whether or not I want to add another school to my application list.