Hey guys,
I'm a little late at replying to this, but I have been lurking this message board for a few days and decided to seize an opportunity and post up. This was especially important since you both are interested in religion, my main research interest. It's pretty hard to come by people who name it as their main interest.
I'm coming from a bit of a different circumstance than the both of you. I am 23, and I just graduated (August) with my MA in Applied Sociology from the University of Central Florida. Currently I am preparing for the whole application process, and have some of the schools you guys mentioned in my top (good mention on Baylor, especially if you have a research interest in religion). Anyway, I presented at the ASR and ASA this year (they were both in San Fran during the same time), too bad I hadn't found this site before then. Sounds like we all have our doubts, yet are aiming quite high.
I guess I should stop rambling (save it for an 'advice' post or something) and say GOOD LUCK to everyone applying.