I am applying to M.S./M.A. programs in secondary education (specifically mathematics). I opted to get letters from my first college math professor (he is the reason I decided to major in mathematics), my boss at the private tutoring company I work for, and my undergraduate thesis advisor. I actually graduate in a few days with my MS in mathematics and statistics but opted not to get any letters from professors here, as I never had a professor more than once and did not feel that they would know me well enough to decide whether or not I would be a great educator. My concern rests in that decision, as well as in the length of my first college math professor's LOR length. It is as follows:
"To Whom This May Concern:
Orthogonalcode was a student of mine in Calculus 1 during the spring 2007 semester and in Calculus 2 during the fall 2007 semester. She was driven to succeed in both of those classes, and she succeeded impressively. Orthogonalcode was a little shy about asking questions in class, but she was relentless about getting them answered after class. She attended my office hours at least once a week. She never procrastinated. If she had a question, she made sure it was cleared up within a day or two. Her work was always neatly organized and complete. I have been teaching at the post-secondary level for over 30 years, and I cannot remember another student who put more care and effort in their work.
From my experience as her instructor, I am convinced that Orthogonalcode will succeed in any course of study she elects. However, I am glad she is interested in mathematics education. She is the kind of person we need in our mathematics classrooms.
Sincerely,
Brilliant professor"
When I first read it, I was really happy with it. However, upon reading posts on this forum, I feel it may not be specific enough. Thoughts?