menge
-
Posts
205 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Posts posted by menge
-
-
8 hours ago, jmarvin_ said:
So does no response from UVA at this point imply rejection?
Probably. My experience with UVA last year is that they send admits and waitlists about now, also some rejections. They also seem to keep a pile of apps in reserve in case they burn through the waitlist, though for practical purposes if you haven't been notified it is likely a rejection.
-
On 1/10/2018 at 12:33 PM, marXian said:
This is actually a really good feeling to learn to control and tame. It doesn't ever really go away. But getting into a program is just the first step in a long process of continually applying for things and waiting for rejection with a few joyous acceptances peppered in. That's a lot of what academia is, tbh. Conferences, journal submissions, fellowship and grant proposals, the job market. All academics submit themselves to these things, all academics have these moments of panic, and all academics experience rejection. The key is not to allow the rejections to speak to who you are as a person, which, I think we get trained to do in our graduate programs, especially at the PhD level.
As everyone has pointed out, there are so many contingencies--things that are beyond your control that, should they lead to rejection, have nothing to do with your abilities as a scholar, your intelligence, and certainly not your worth as a person. It's the most frustrating thing ever (though the job market is worse), but accepting that this is just part of how it works mitigates some of that frustration (at least for me.)
wholeheartedly agree with this.
-
18 hours ago, Averroes MD said:
Which citation manager do you recommend ?
I use Mendeley- many faculty and friends I know use EndNote. I use Mendeley because its free and has most of the functionality I desire: cloud sync for access from multiple devices, ability to open doc and annotate in program, searchibility, MS Word integration. Though my University gives us a free subscription to EndNotes, I don't know where I'll be in the future and don't want to deal with the hassle of migrating libraries to a new software. Might be worth talking to folks who work in a similar area to you and see what they use. There might be some features that a certain program has that could be useful in your area/subdiscipline.
-
I'll second the tablet, second monitor, and Prime suggestions. I'll add that a citation manager can be a tremendous tool, if used well. I have mine synced to the cloud so that I can access articles on my tablet, annotate them, and access them later on my laptop/desktop. It's also a huge timesaver for formatting bibliographies.
-
23 hours ago, JDD said:
@menge Wow - I had no idea that was the case. I supposed that partially explains why the best PhD programs are so competitive. What do you believe most contributed to the success of your PHD applications?
The biggest thing that helped me was that I had met my potential advisors, they had seen me present work at conferences, and our interests aligned very well. The two schools I had this in place I was accepted. That said, I had good e-mail interactions with other potential advisors which got me at least thoroughly considered at a couple of other schools, though the didn't end up in acceptances for various reasons (not enough faculty to support my interests, etc.). Beside establishing contact with an advisor, the other important things (which you will read elsewhere as well): do well on the GRE (this helped get me a University wide fellowship in my current program which means more $$), make sure you apply to schools with people that can support your interests (the so-called "fit" metric), and polish the heck out of your writing sample and personal statements. If you are able, have a faculty member at the school you want to get in to read your personal statement and offer suggestions. They will know what their committee is looking for. Most of this stuff you can read more about in old threads on this forum.
-
6 hours ago, bijou2017 said:
Hey everyone, quick question. So I submitted an app for the religious studies MA at Arizona State University, then received an email from a POI saying after a quick look at my application, he thinks I'm a better fit for the PhD program, which also has full funding.
I was curious if anyone knows much about ASU's PhD program (I can't find current grad students online, or even how many are there right now), or has any thoughts on this. I'm a little surprised by all this, their deadline isn't until Jan 15 (I submitted less than a week ago), and the POI offered to help me refine my personal statement in preparation for the PhD application.
From what I know, ASU has strengths geared toward anthropology of religion. Depending on your interests and potential supervisor, it certainly is a good option. Plenty of folks with MA's get shut out every year, so getting one is no guarantee of getting into a PhD. If you get a PhD offer in lieu of MA, I would strongly consider it (pending the outcomes of your other apps of course).
-
14 minutes ago, JDD said:
@PhD Hopeful Thanks for the feedback - fuller certainly isn't off the list. I have a wonderful conversation with their admissions director where he confirmed that they do offer a handful of full-ride scholarships. Perhaps things have changed since @marXian attended, regarding scholarships. Still - I don't think anyone can really count on receiving an acceptance letter, much less a huge scholarship, so I'm not holding my breath.
Can you speak to what financial aid looks like for most Ph.D programs?
The only PhD worth doing is one that is completely funded. The best programs will cover all your tuition, give you health insurance, a stipend of $20-$30k, and offer some money for travel to conferences/research/etc. Some other programs will be similar, but offer less by way of the stipend (state schools tend to run lower). Depending on where you go and what your offer looks like, you may or may not be required to teach as art of your assistantship. And then there are other fellowships which you might qualify for based on GPA's, GRE's, etc.
-
On 12/4/2017 at 3:46 AM, LotusFlower said:
Hi All!
Had a great time reading this thread. Wanted to pop in quickly and ask a quick question. Because so many schools caution their applicants by saying how limited their funding is, I wanted to know how many of you received funding as a result of merit or need-based financial aid. Did you fill out the FAFSA?
FWIW, I filled out FAFSA but didn't use it since I didn't want loans. My assistantship covered tuition, stipend wasn't massive but I was fortunate as my partner was working and making enough to support us. I do believe several in my program did use FAFSA, mostly for money to be able to live off of.
-
Depending on what NRMs you're into, that could take you a few places.
In terms of MA's, Western Michigan is a funded MA with a faculty member specializing in NRMs. Not my field, but I took two courses with him and both were fantastic.
I know UCSB is a place people are doing work on NRMs. You might also look at UVA, as they have a couple great Americanists. I'm sure others can make suggestions too based on schools they attended or researched.
-
FWIW, i know of a number of Marquette PhD grads that are teaching at evangelical institutions, so that shouldn't limit you long term, if that's your goal.
-
9 hours ago, FearNTrembling said:
Looking to eventually do doctoral work in Theology/Religion. Here's my situation:
I will be completing my MTS at the end of this year from a fairly conservative seminary. I have a 4.0, I've presented three papers at seminars/conferences within my university, and I have three professors who have offered to write letters of recommendation. My particular interests are philosophy of religion (analytic & continental), historical theology (post-Enlightenment) and religious pluralism. I am toying with applying to a second master's program (MA/MDiv) at a top-tier school to improve my application for doctoral programs. I have received a great education in my current program, but I'm also aware of the intensity of the application process. Plus, I'm in a place in my life where I could realistically pursue a second master's.
-Would having a MTS (positively/negatively) impact my chances for admission in a MDiv program at HDS, Yale, Princeton, Duke, etc.?
-Would any of those MDiv programs likely include any of my MTS coursework as advanced-standing credits?
-Would a second master's really make a difference as far as applications are concerned?
My 2cents after both myself and my office-mate were shut out of religion programs this season, with an MA from a state school: the second MA may not be necessary or what helps you, but the degree from a top tier school will. Between the two of us we received interviews and waitlists, and acceptances outside of religion, but I imagine that when pitted against shiny degrees from Ivy schools and big-name LOR's, our dossiers just couldn't hold up, despite 10+ conference presentations and publications. I should add, this is already my 2nd MA. Where you go matters.
Of course there are likely more things at play as well: where we applied, our particular interests, etc. But I do think an Ivy MA would have made the difference.
-
3 hours ago, seung said:
I'm off the waitlist at UVA! Ecstatic!
Congrats! Glad it worked out for you.
-
Finally got the official rejection from UVA. Hopefully this means they are getting closer to releasing (good!) news to those of you on the WL.
-
15 hours ago, seung said:
Is anyone else having trouble with UVA's online application? Also, could these schools just get back to us already?
Seems to be working fine for me, though still no decision from them.
-
10 hours ago, rheya19 said:
I'm not really clear on some of the language surrounding programs. I understand what Ivy League and R1 are, but what do you mean by "ranked?" Ranked where?
As you allude to, religion doesn't have formal "rankings." However, a number of other disciplines do, even if they are somewhat contentious. Philosophy has the PGR rankings, for example, and a number of other disciplines have similar rankings. In my case, the ranking is published every three years by the disciplinary equivalent of the AAR based on a number of different criteria including faculty research productivity, PhD productivity, PhD funding availability, placement, etc. etc.
-
-
12 hours ago, rheya19 said:
When I interviewed with Iowa a few weeks ago, one of their questions for me was, "What is your dream position after graduating, and what is a second option you would like if you couldn't do the first?" I actually appreciated the question, because it shows that they recognize the crisis in the job market, and they probably want students who have thought seriously about that.
I think we all have to start thinking creatively about what we have to offer the job market and education in general. The game is changing very rapidly.
I had a similar experience at Temple, but pre-application. I had a phone call with a would be POI after a few e-mails back and forth. We had a great conversation, and she agreed to support my application there (Temple apps require a faculty sponsor) but was very clear that their recent placement record was poor and that it was a bad decision to attend there. I made the decision not to apply there since I already had an acceptance at a ranked program in another discipline, even though religious studies is/would have been my first choice as a discipline to work in. In retrospect, not being in religious studies will likely be a boon to my job prospects upon graduation.
-
29 minutes ago, xypathos said:
Sounds like Union pulled a "We're not their first choice so if accepted somewhere else they'll turn us down. So, lets find a reason to rescind the offer." Which is easy enough to do.
Something similar happened at Michigan last year in the Anthropology dept. Notices of acceptance were erroneously posted on the application portal of numerous applicants, only to change to rejections a day or so later. They ended up refunding a lot of application fees. What a fiasco.
-
1 hour ago, seung said:
What does it mean to be provisionally accepted
It might be institution dependent, but the way it was explained to me was that it provisional/conditional admission is granted until they receive all my official transcripts and confirm that my MA was conferred, etc. So it allows me to register for Fall classes, but I have to graduate with my MA and send in transcripts to be unconditionally accepted.
Though in the Union case above, it seems to have meant something different.
-
-
43 minutes ago, bijou2017 said:
Any thoughts from anyone about if it's too soon to contact a school to ask if they've made any decisions, or when we could expect decisions?
I contacted schools the last week in Feb. At this point, most have released their first round of decisions. I think its perfectly acceptable to send a short email to the grad. studies coordinator, or your POI if you have a relationship. Everyone got back to me within a few hours and they extremely professional and helpful.
-
47 minutes ago, Person11 said:
Does anyone know how long it usually takes before good or bad news comes to the waitlisted at ND and Marquette? I'm trying to figure out if it's worth waiting, or if I should accept another offer soon. For the sake of the program I've been accepted to, I'm not keen on waiting until April 15. The chair at ND said that, as a rule, it doesn't drag out too long, but I'm not sure what that means.
Don't worry about the program; this decision is about you. They already have the power, and will find someone for the slot if they really want it. Take your time and make the best decision for yourself.
-
Just received an official rejection from UPenn via e-mail. My season is finally over!
-
OK friends, I need a little advice in decision making. I'm pretty sure I have a decision made, but a little confirmation from others would help me feel more comfortable.
Presuming rejections from UVA, and UPenn (I didn't receive admit/waitlist at UVA, and no interview at UPenn), I will have struck out on Religious Studies programs. I do have admits to two programs in another discipline, both of which I would be happy with. One program is ranked T3 in the discipline and the other is T25 (both are flagship State U's). The catch is, the offer from T25 is solid and includes a nomination for a university fellowship. The department has also gone way above and beyond to get me to accept their offer. The funding at T3 is in limbo due to a state budget crises, and won't be made available probably until May. Despite the difference in ranking, this seems like a no-brainer, and I'm thinking I should accept T25.
Two additional notes: the fellowship comes with publication requirements. In the first year, it would require 1 sole authored paper and 1 co-authored paper. In subsequent years that bumps up to 1 sole author paper and 2 co-author papers. Are these kind of parameters normal for fellowship awards? The prospect seems to both exciting and daunting at the same time.
Last, the program would be in more of a social science discipline, though most of my theory & methods training could be completed in Religious Studies/Hist./Anthro. etc. and I would have an RS faculty member serve on my dissertation committee (this has already been pitched to her). I would also have summer teaching opportunities in the RS dept. With some cognate coursework in RS, an MA in RS, RS teaching experience as both an MA and PhD student, and a dissertation which is focused on RS what is the likelihood I'd be able to cross over and teach in RS?
PhD Applications Fall '18 Season
in Religion
Posted
missed this before, but my experience: it definitely matters, especially depending on the perceived quality of your undergrad. go to the best MA you can. if not funded, go to best MA with funding.