Just my advice as a current PhD student. Unless your situation is really no funding vs. great funding, the question of "fit" is the MOST important thing. If your interests don't fit in well with your department, your chances of getting a job will drop significantly unless you are a truly amazing scholar (meaning you have already published,etc.). That being said, it is only your relationship with your adviser/chair that needs to be really close. Departmental orientations are always in flux, even if it doesn't really seem that way from the outside. You need to have a sense of who specifically you want to work with at each university, communicate with them by phone or e-mail, and then make your decision. Congratulations on your acceptances!