Some of my co-workers have done the NYU program and have wonderful things to say about it. I personally am not really planning on staying in NYC. I'm from where the Midwest meets the Northeast, went to school in Texas, and I've always found myself feeling more connected to the Midwest which is where a lot of the schools I'm applying to are. If you're interested in living in NYC, I'd say go for NYU. Pratt is definitely the best LIS program in NYC though. A lot of the faculty work for the best library institutions in the city including the New York Public Library.