This is just another example of what is now well known about the GRE. That is, it doesn't say jack about a student's academic potential, it actually predicts socio-economic background more than anything else. Why is a long story, but trust me on that, there is a lot of data. My Master's program accepted the MAT, and I took that because it is actually meant to be a measure of a person's basic intelligence profile. I too scored very high on that test and scored like a dope on the GRE. The GRE is nothing but a test of one's ability to do academic tricks for profit, profit that is accumulated by a massive multinational corporate testing monopoly. Further, I have it on really, really good intel that unless you are in a strict science or mathematical field, the GRE is increasingly being seen by admissions committees as little more than a hoop their applicants have to jump through. I have a low GRE score, but I am cited in the bibliography of one of the professors in the program I am applying to, and I have been published multiple times. What did I get on the writing? Like a 4.5. I think I forgot how to write a 5th grade essay. The short story is: focus on your SOP, your writing/research sample, and your letters. The GRE is a joke against all that, especially if you have a killer GPA, which you do!!!