DigDeep(inactive)

I'm confused at your lack of self-confidence. You have great experience, a decent GPA (if it's low 3 point then it's just average, not really a big deal). If you do well enough (slightly above or above average) on GRE, then the GPA won't matter too much, anyways. Don't sell yourself short. You should apply to American, GWU, SAIS, and anywhere else you think fits well with your research interests.

I'll assume you mean in general, rather than BU specifically. So, I would have to say that I think there is nothing wrong with that at all. It's a definite opportunity to gain some insight. I interviewed for a job last month and made it to the short list. When I got the call that I did not get it, I asked if there was anything I could do to improve for future jobs (including interview style or credentials). He told me things about my application that he loved and where I fell short. Of course, no one is ever obligated to tell you anything, but if they do then it is extremely helpful, as in my case. It's unfortunate that you got such a unsympathetic and almost callous (it sounds) response from your POI at BU. But, I would brush it off move forward. As others have said, it IS beneficial that he was blunt and you won't have to waste valuable time or money applying again.

Good luck HrdyWordy. Sending positive vibes your way, friend.

Aren't you the one who said you are interested in Bioarchaeology and burials? If so, I would assume that you were not accepted due to lack of fit, and not your grades. Unless I'm mistaken, BU is not really known for doing Bioarch. In fact, I don't know any prof there that does it. If I'm wrong, my apologies. Regardless, hang in there Daisy123!

Still waiting on Boston. My only app. Going to stay positive!

Anyone applying to, have recently been accepted in, or have begun a career in Science Journalism or Writing? I am finishing up my Masters and am on the fence on if I should continue with a PhD. Academia does not seem as appealing as it once did. I'm open to any insight on your experiences, recent or old. How is it? Was it what you expected? Which schools are the best?