I contacted Max Friesen back in the fall about coming to Toronto for graduate studies in arctic archaeology. He was very personable over email and even gave me some articles to read. He did warn me, however, about the near impossibility of getting accepted as an international applicant. To add to it, I was applying to the PhD program as direct-entry (just finished my BA this spring). Basically I had two marks against me already, but I applied anyway. There aren't many arctic archaeology programs out there and Toronto/Friesen really seem like a good fit for me. And from what I've been told by my referees and colleagues in the field, Toronto is a reputable school whose name carries some cachet (which I'm hoping will help later on when I enter the job market). Maybe this judgement on reputation is different from a Canadian perspective?
I also like the idea of getting out of Illinois.
P.S. This is my second time around applying to schools. Last year, I kind of winged it and was met with across the board rejections. I was shortlisted at WashU, and after I drove down for interviews, it was clear that my interests didn't line up with those of the faculty as well as I had thought. This time I started earlier, did more research, and made sure to contact faculty well ahead of time. Honestly, this unexpected time off has been great. I've been able to get more job experience and I have the time to work on getting an article ready for publication. So for those still waiting, don't despair if you aren't successful this round! Keep your head up and use your time off to build up your CV.