Initially tending for the first one, I was forced to reconsider once I was presented with the funding offer.
Reputation and Research topic is a tie. Its a matter of funding now I think
McGill
10k for first and second year then all relies on external funding (grant applications + RA+ TA, cant do TA and RA on first year)
NYU
23k for 4 years
NYU is clearly a better offer. However cost of life is much higher too, so I dont actually know where would life be harder. Montreal means that I will have to find external funding and possibly a part-time job, so very unstable and unsure. My personality is definetely closer to montreal rather than ny (which it aint bad at all but i like quieter places).