I applied to the Theological Studies subfield and got waitlisted today. So, to all who are being interviewed in theology this weekend, if Baylor isn't your top choice, please decline if they give you an offer! I'd love to be there.
That's encouraging. I have a similar background, and similar exam scores as you. I thought that meant I had meager chances. I think I have great LORs and a solid SOP - so, your story encourages me in that my educational pedigree won't necessarily do me in from the start. I'm not applying to Duke or any of the top-tier programs (mostly just second-tier).