Thank you (both) for such a thoughtful and thorough response!
I live in sunny California, and while I would enjoy experiencing snow every now and again, I worry about my mental health in dreary Syracuse (thanks for providing a bright side, though: LOL "be prepared to make your own fun!"). The university seems like a wonderful fit, so it's definitely a tough call for me.
I hope you have a wonderful graduate experience wherever you choose to go. Herself the elf, thanks for the invitation--I might send you a message regarding your experience as a student. What schools are you considering?