I was in a very similar situation. Both of my mentors graduated from the same, very well respected, CJ program and they were pushing me in that direction. I had the unfortunate duty to tell them this week that I would not be attending that school. Neither was very happy with my decision, but at the end of the day I chose what's best for me. That's what you need to do as well. Your mentors may know a lot about you, but you know yourself best. You are the expert in this situation - only YOU know what's best for you. If one school seems right, then it is. Don't doubt yourself or your intuition. Good luck!