Not sure which section this belongs in. I'm a 22-year-old MA (History) student from Toronto and I've applied to begin my PhD in the same. I'm a dual citizen of America and Canada (it becomes relevant). I've applied to a few universities, but the relevant facts here are as follows. UC Davis has accepted me; it was my first choice, tied with UofT. UofT declined me. I'm still waiting on a reply from uOttawa.
Davis is a great opportunity with some amazing supervisors, and from what I've heard funding can be an issue for international students which it won't be for me given my citizenship. The thing is I've lived at home my entire life and wanted to stay here for my PhD so I wouldn't have to uproot my whole life. I did my undergrad and am currently doing my MA at UofT. The consensus seems to be that three degrees from the same university is frowned upon in academia, though it wasn't such a concern for me because I'm not looking to stay in academia after I get my PhD. Anyway, I was really excited and so sure I wanted to do this. I still am. If Toronto accepted me I would've gone through with it in a heartbeat. I'm just scared right now, for the first time in a long time. It's not the workload that's putting me off; I enjoy that for some weird, fucked up reason. It's moving. It won't even be that bad because I can come back to Toronto after 2 years (coursework + comps). I just can't get my head past the idea about physically being 4,000 km from my family and friends.
So based on this I have two questions. I'm running the same thing by a couple of my profs, though I would like the grad student perspective, too. I would appreciate your opinions.
I. Is it standard to have these sorts of second thoughts about moving?
II. If uOttawa accepts me, it's that or Davis. Academically, Davis is better for me as I am a US historian and from what I've been told, it's difficult to get an academic position as a US historian with a Canadian PhD. However I want to do something administrative with my PhD, though still probably in the States. Given this, do there appear to be any downsides to Ottawa assuming funding is similar-ish? Ottawa is a few hours from home, so I would be a lot more comfortable there.