Oh no! Not this top 10 thing again! Ultimately, I think one person's top 10 will look very different from another. For example, if you were interested in Egyptian art, I don't think you would be looking at those programs at all. Rather, you might be inclined to look at Emory. Likewise, if you are interested in 18th cent painting, Harvard might be on your list and Berkeley (but Lynn Hunt isn't there anymore). But, you might want to look at Iowa (Dorothy Johnson), Missouri (Michal Yonan), and Wisconsin (Jill Casid, Suzanne Desan in history and they have quite a few lit theory folks). Long story short, I'd go with an advisor who is well known in an area that you are interested in. Granted, I'd also take it as contingent upon what funding package you get. If you get a good funding package 4-5 years guaranteed and have a top notch advisor doing work in your field, you are probably at a good place.
For anyone in the admissions process, I want to stress that above all else, you should go to a play where you think you can formulate the best dissertation committee that you can. By best, I mean people who will push you to produce the absolute best work you can produce and folks who are willing to give you feedback on in class papers in order to turn them into publishable essays (I have many friends who wish they got any feedback at all on seminar papers).