Thanks to all three of you for your replies. I've been mulling over your responses the past few days, which is why I'm replying a tad late.
The three graduate courses I have taken thus far have all been within Women's Studies, in which I am pursuing a graduate certificate in addition to my undergrad degrees.
Second, next semester, I will be taking a graduate English class, and it will be the first graduate course I will have taken in English.. I'm minoring in English, so I will have taken about four or five English classes total by the time I send in my applications next fall.
And I completely agree with all of you that there is a value in taking time off. I just lose my sanity a bit when I'm not actively researching/sharing in a structured environment-- deadlines and pressure make me feel pretty alive, I guess.
I also understand these programs are ridiculously competitive; I really wish I had known things I know now (duh, as we all do) when I started my undergrad-- I would've focused more on languages and majored in comparative literature and wmst. I am worried that people with entire BAs in English will be a lot more appealing; I'm also hoping, on the other hand, that committees look for diversity in undergraduate studies but a demonstrated ability to conduct literary research.
And to answer you Chumlee, yes. I am seeking to draw on my background in wmst and philosophy. Luckily, because I have been taken graduate seminars, I feel pretty confident in my "direction." It has forced me to critically examine my work and ask myself: "Why academia at all?" I have passing moments of crisis, "fraud syndrome," etc., but I feel that taking graduate courses has definitely instilled a level of reality that most undergrads don't have in terms of what "going to grad school" even means.
I love that you mentioned geography, papillon. This is extremely important to me. I would absolutely love living in a big city-- it seems coextensive, for me, with the "big move" that is graduate school. I've lived in small cities and and metro Atlanta (not a real city, at all) for far too long!