Seems we are in the same committee. I got waitlisted as well. At the point of application, I had 7 publications (4 first authorships); over 10 conference presentations and industrial technical reports; OGS; Mitacs; 3 internal scholarships and some other small scholarships and still did not even get PGS-D. Ofcourse I have bunch of extracurriculars as well. A friend in the same department as me had similar profile as me but with little previous scholarships, my overall grades (both grad and undergrad) are better than her, but with 10 publications (only 1 first authorship) and end up getting CGS-D. She had 2 scholarships and all those scholarships, I already have won them. She have a winning package but so do I, and I am just not sure what went wrong. This is my second time of applying, I have one more to apply.