I'll try to be brief, as this seems to be a common question from most wary members of this forum. I took the GRE last week and got a 650 verbal, 740 math (a somewhat surprising score - on PowerPrep I was averaging 720 verbal, 650 math). As for my other background, I graduated magna cum laude and Phi Beta Kappa from a top-10 university (and also achieved honors in my major). I'm currently working towards my Masters at an Oxbridge university on a full scholarship. My undergrad GPA was about a 3.93, and my major-GPA was a 4.0 (weighted)/3.98 (unweighted). I'm hoping that my application accoutrements (recs/writing sample/statement of purpose) will be strong.
As for schools, I'm considering applying to programs in South Asian history at: Columbia, Princeton, Harvard, Chicago, Berkeley, and Tufts. I'm also applying to the Soros Fellowship for New Americans, the Javits Fellowship, and the Ford Fellowship (I'm a minority, but not in a category that is 'severely underrepresented' in the academy).
My adviser has told me that I have a strong application and that GRE scores will never make or break an application (he also told me that the number one factor in admissions tends to be departmental politics ). But, as silly as this may be, I just don't feel confident about my verbal score: a 650 tends to hover at the average (but below the median) at these universities. I'm also concerned that dropping $160 dollars on a retake may lead to an improvement in my verbal score, but a backslide into my PowerPrep averages on math (thus perhaps keeping my total score the same).
What are your opinions on my score? Any help would be appreciated.
Many thanks!