Boston College has a brand new MA in theology and philosophy (jointly offered by the two departments) that you might check out. I don't know if it's explicit in the recruiting literature they've produced, but they want a mix of people who are thinking about more advanced studies, people who want to teach at the secondary level, and people who are just looking for academic enrichment. It might be a very good fit for you. The catch is that they're not currently offering any funding, but you can sometimes find an on-campus job that's not attached to any particular program or department that includes tuition remission.
http://www.bc.edu/schools/gsas/academics/masters_programs/ma-phil-theo.html
