I'm an older student (coming back to school) and I have 18 years of painting/exhibiting self-taught and a B.A in painting (last three years )
I went to the San Francisco (at the Art Institute) Grad Portfolio Review this past Sunday, 10-9-11...
here the spill:
I sat down with the following schools ( I wish I had talked to more of them, but the event was from 12PM to 4PM and these interviews were fairly long)
SAIC
Had a real positive review. After I showed my portfolio and sort of articulated why and how I'm going about doing my work, she then told me she liked the work and that she felt I'd be a good candidate because I didn't say I had arrived at any conclusions and on the contrary, that I expressed I was seeking to explore further new ways of creating interesting art.
RISD
The reviewer basically said he also liked the work I was showing him and that I just had to make sure my statement covered everything that I expressed on the interview, as far as explaining it.
SVA - The guy who reviewed my work and I had some things in common and this was the only reason why I'd consider this school. He is in the Computer Arts program (and I've worked with computers and multimedia as a career for over 15 years). This school seems to be a good environment for a painter that wants to explore other methods (such as digital processes, large format printers etc) as potential part of the work flow.
SFAI -
I spoke to the director of art faculty and he is a conceptual artist. If you look at the link to his work there are almost no images. Nice guy, really interesting but I started feeling like perhaps I'd not be a good match for that school. So at one point I just asked bluntly: "so do you think it would be a waste of my time to apply here, since it seems you guys have this interdisciplinary focus to your programs?" To what he replied: "No, absolutely not! As a matter of fact I want you to go to that table over there (it was manned by one of the painting faculty) and speak to that guy". Again, once I sat with the painting dude, basically he also really liked my paintings and even went as far as saying that he'd would put a referral for me in case I applied there.
Well, since my current work is really new even to me, I was humbled by the experience. It gave me confidence to really go for broke and deal with the next few years (student loans et all), quit my two jobs and leave my current career on hold. But I'm an older, seasoned guy and I believe in my work ethic and on the sliver of talent that I believe drives this whole madness of going back to school seeking an MFA.
Also I have 6 years of Community College teaching experience. I like teaching, so if I get accepted, and at the end I'm not a hot shot exhibiting artist, then I have teaching to fall back on.
I hope this helps...