Here's the broadly painted picture: I'm applying for PhD programs in History; 2.9 undergrad GPA in theology; 3.75 grad GPA in theology; 2 years international teaching experience in history; 90th percentile verbal; 36th in math; 29th in analytical writing; 3 stellar recommendations; a solid statement of purpose essay; and a great writing sample. The analytical writing score came as an unpleasant surprise.
I anticipated a score of around 5 instead of 3.5, but I believe I was hurt significantly by the fact that I was not able to finish one of the essays within 30 minutes. Wasn't sure if they would simply score what I had, or if not finishing would hurt. I guess now I know.
Still, in light of everything else, would it be advisable to re-take the GRE? Is it possible to re-take one section only, since I truly do not want to mess with the verbal score? Is it possible to do this while continuing to apply for Fall 2012?
Thanks for any thoughts!