Hi all,
I've been following this forum rather obsessively for the past month or so, so I thought I would post.
I applied in a previous cycle, and was universally rejected from every PhD program I applied to. I got into a wonderful funded master's program, though, and I think my scholarship has strengthened as a result of two extra years of graduate-level study. I also think I have a stronger application, which will hopefully help.
I have had the opportunity to meet and interact on a professional level with every POI I applied to work with. Whether this will help me or not, I'm not sure. But when I e-mailed them last September/October they said that they remembered me and encouraged me to apply. Perhaps the best benefit of contacting professors, especially meeting him/her in person, is that they will remember your name/face when they read your application. You aren't just a name on a page- they know that you're a real human being. I don't think that not meeting or contacting your advisors beforehand will hurt you- but I think it does certainly help if you decide to get in touch with them.
Due to circumstances largely beyond my control, there are portions of my application that aren't as strong as I would've liked them to be. I've sort of come to terms with the fact that if I'm not accepted this time around, I will come back with an even better application next year with a completed master's thesis in tow. It's not that I'm giving up- it's all about trying to be realistic. So if I get in to any of the programs that I apply to, I think it will largely be due to the fact that I've met the professors, have great letters of rec, and have completed two more years of study at the grad-level.
I think it's really wonderful that so many of you have had such positive news already! I can't wait to see how this turns out you all. For better or worse, we're all in this academia thing for the long haul. Good luck to everyone.
Is it Monday yet?