they said that the classes were underwhelming academically; however, after talking to them once they started their second semester classes, they said it is a lot better. i think the foundation courses can feel that way anywhere. as for advice, i wish i could give you some - i am just as torn! i think they are both amazing programs. u of chicago's program is smaller, which i see as a benefit - more individualized attention. to be honest, after researching, i think chicago seems like a better program (smaller, more detailed courses, you take more courses bc of the quarter system - two years is such a small amount of time so you can get as much info as possible with that system, etc.), but i love that columbia is in nyc. what are your thoughts?? i am soooo torn because they are both great programs.