The situation: my BA is in History and Literature (an interdisciplinary degree), and I wrote my thesis on historical philosophy. I'm currently applying to art history PhD programs. I've had a good deal of art history coursework, plus a hefty quantity of independent study (that is to say, I am not insecure about my ability to hold my own in graduate-level art history studies).
The query: what to do for my writing sample. My thesis, which I am incredibly proud of and believe represents my best writing and scholarship, is over 100 pages, but my last chapter (given some editing) could probably stand on its own. As I said, I believe it represents my best work, but it's definitely not an art history paper. I have art history papers from courses I took, all of them good, but nothing as strong as my thesis.
So, what's more important? Good writing and critical thinking, or topicality?
Ready, go!
Thanks everyone!