This question might be moot because it may be field specific and I am not sure if the OP is still around.
But are you guys specifically looking at US News and World Report for program ranking? Or is it more subjective than that?
I know the OP said if you have to ask, it is not in the top 25... but if you are coming from outside the field this distinction is harder to discern.
Also, I have heard many in my field be very dismissive of the US News and World Report rankings and pointing out its flaws. They seem to put more stock
in productivity of faculty, quantity and quality of pubs, grants awarded, funding, etc...