qeta
-
Posts
276 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Posts posted by qeta
-
-
I agree with the previous poster. I am "diverse" by various metrics and am close to a few people with lifelong diabetes. Chronic diabetes is a serious issue that you have needed to manage. The goal of diversity-based fellowships is to reward you for overcoming a significant adversity and to somewhat ease the unfair burden on you of having to navigate the ablist, sexist, racist, etc., academy. So I'd say you definitely qualify for general diversity-based fellowships or fellowships specifically geared towards disabled students.
-
On 5/16/2022 at 4:40 PM, cangrad11 said:
Thanks for this! I'm also at a pretty wealthy private institution in the US and on an existing internal fellowship, and I don't think i'm fully aware of any mandatory reporting rules, so the idea that I would get paid directly from SSHRC then have to return some of it is..... a lot. Just not sure if folks have heard of students at their institutions who have been in similar situations and not had their original stipends reduced and if so, what %.
I’m on an internal fellowship too, which is paid via direct deposit in monthly installments. If I end up getting SSHRC, the university HR would deposit a smaller amount each month and I’d keep the SSHRC money. If I were you, I would ask around discretely about the ramifications of not declaring an award. Maybe ask trustworthy graduate students from your department who are no longer at the institution? I personally don’t see a huge problem with not giving more money to private institutions with endowments many times larger than the GDP of most countries. I wouldn’t do it because I study difference and punishment and know that I can’t afford to take those kinds of risks. Plus, my school has a record of being litigious against students.
-
You can still put on your CV that you were an alternate and declined to be considered for the award.
-
13 hours ago, cangrad11 said:
@qeta @remote13 @Burner_Question @Burner_Answer @NateL
I had a question for Canadian students getting this in the US or other foreign institutions. The award guidelines say we get the award paid directly: https://www.nserc-crsng.gc.ca/Students-Etudiants/Guides-Guides/TriRTA-TriBFR_eng.asp#other
Do folks have a sense of whether our institutions can claw back the money we get or not? For example, would we have to hand over the money to our department and they correspondingly reduce our existing stipend? Ive heard this happens a lot with domestic fellowships and also in Canada, for example it happens with the Ford predoctoral fellowship at my school.
At my very rich, private institution, we have to inform the department and the graduate school when we win awards. There’s a cap on how much we can earn per year (1.xx times our regular stipend amount). The school lets us keep the award, but reduces the stipend amount so that we don’t go over the max amount.
-
On 5/2/2022 at 5:54 PM, SoleilSunshinee said:
Hi everyone, I emailed my university to ask whether I was on any form of waitlist as I was so close to the cutoff. They explained: there are three possible options for each student. Recommended, Recommended but not funded, and not offered.
According to the person I was talking with, I was recommended but not funded. Even they explained they dont 100% know if this is a waitlist. I will contact SSHRC and ask what does it all mean. If there is no waitlist, what then happens to the funds? It is also confusing cause on my own application on the portal it says « not offered » so what does « recommended but not funded » mean?
Will update for anyone that is in the same boat as me.
I’m a direct applicant from the US. When I asked SSHRC whether I was on a waitlist because I was 6 spots away from the last awardee, a staff member emailed me the following.
“SSHRC has offered all of the awards associated with this year’s competition to those recommended for funding by this year’s merit review committee. While selection committees often recommend a pool of candidates to whom funding cannot be offered due to program success rates*, we regret that we cannot predict if or when alternate offers can be made.
Unforeseen circumstances may occasionally allow SSHRC to offer awards to meritorious candidates who indicated interest but who were not offered an award at the time of the release of results. Please rest assured that we work with these award holders to ensure that late offers can be held.
Should we be in a position to offer an award before the end of the calendar year, we will contact you by email.”
So if you’re in the “recommended but not offered” group, there is a chance you may get the award before January 1, 2023. Please correct me if I’m misinterpreting the email.
*The phrase “program success rates” led to this link: https://www.sshrc-crsh.gc.ca/results-resultats/stats-statistiques/index-eng.aspx -
I love workshops! They generally focus on a specific topic, especially emerging topics of interest (e.g.: the relationship between property and racialization across the world), and are generally interdisciplinary. Participants are asked to read carefully and comment constructively and collegially on each other’s works, so the feedback is usually good. Everybody gives tons of reading recommendations so it’s a great way to understand the state of the field. More importantly, because everybody works on related topics that are usually niche or new, people have an incentive to build an intellectual community during and beyond the workshop.
Your comments about conferences make a lot of sense. Because I’m in the middle years of my PhD program, I stopped finding medium to large conferences helpful. From what my advisors tell me, they will be helpful again in the next couple of years, at least for networking. -
10 hours ago, Quicksilver25 said:
They were a mix of provincial and institutional conferences.
I find this talk of conferences fascinating! I’m in sociology in the US and have presented at 10+ international and national conferences and workshops, including a very prestigious dissertation workshop. I think of conference presentations as a way to demonstrate that I’m involved in the disciplinary community and/or that I’m working on a manuscript. Most professors and grad students in my program present at conferences, almost as an annual ritual. Can somebody tell me why conference participation signals merit? Is it a discipline-specific thing? (I partly want to know because I truly hate huge conferences—they generally involve vague feedback and are costly to participate in—and much prefer workshops.)
-
18 minutes ago, Sora.K said:
The biggest difference lied in research potential. His research topic seemed to have been liked quite a bit more than mine. Also while my PhD focuses on a completely new topic his builds on his master's. I think that the reviewers like that kind of narrative in the proposal.
This is my reading of SSHRC and Canadian awards in general. They really do seem to prefer if the applicant expands their MA research during doctoral studies. Possibly the adjudicators think that the applicant has a better grounding in the topic and is more likely to finish the PhD/project if they focused on the same during their MA. In my experience, the US awards evaluators don’t focus on this dimension because most PhD programs are direct entry. Not sure what would counteract this, except publishing more, or pointing out that you received a distinction in your exams and are building on that base, or asking your recommenders to comment that you are one of the most knowledgable students they have met.
-
2 hours ago, Ana Lacerda said:
Congratulations to everyone who got it!
I didn't, for 0.15 points... 75 scholarships offered, I ranked 84. I don't know if I got lucky or not (or indifferent) but one of my committee members was a prof who was going to be my supervisor at UOttawa. We exchanged emails and he accepted me, but then OISE results came and I ended up declining my offer. And he was the only one on my committee that was in my broad area.
Do y 'all know if there's such a thing as people not accepting their offers and then others, next in line, getting it? It was my first time applying. I'm second year, so I'm pretty sad especially because I don't know how I am going to continue affording life in Toronto with OISE's base funding... 1,600 per month for RAship/GAship barely pays for a studio basement 1 hour away from campus...
Plus, would you guys say the most important thing is publications? Those of you who got it, could you tell us how many publications you had?
People do move up waitlists and get awards as others ahead of them decline. If you read the previous years’ threads on the SSHRC doctoral fellowship, you'll see upward movement like that. People get other large, multi-year awards like Vanier, Trudeau, and US-based ones or decide to go to international universities. I have acquaintances who have declined an award or become an awardee at a late stage. It's a highly contingent process that plays out over months, so it's probably best to not dwell on it, if possible. (Saying this as a fellow waitlister.)
Also, your worries about an evaluating professor holding a grudge are the stuff of my worst nightmare. I changed countries and disciplines to get away from a political science professor with Napoleonic complex, who shall remain unnamed. On the plus side, your grudge-holding prof will probably not judge your application next year.- Sora.K and Ana Lacerda
-
1
-
1
-
29 minutes ago, SoleilSunshinee said:
I've been doing a lot of research and have found nothing regarding their removal of waitlists. That would be unfortunate that the money simply goes unclaimed unlike prior years. Many students get their financing from being on waitlists (has happened to me in the past).
I’m going to email them at the end of next week asking if the process has changed from waitlist to offered/not offered. Will keep you all posted. (But truly, this information should already be available somewhere.)
-
Scored a 8.81 from committee 752-3A. Ranked 77 and last offer was made to 71 (9.03). Pretty happy with this, considering how terrible my application was!
-
Did anyone else’s application disappear in the portal? Mine did. I can only see my web CV now and, under applications, there is nothing. Is this the normal process?
-
Hi @Day.C, I’m so sorry this happened to you. It sounds super stressful and disheartening. Why don’t you reach out to the SSHRC administrators? I have emailed them before and they do respond in a week or two. Good luck!
-
Congrats to the awardees! I had three reviewers and got mostly good to excellent ratings. It was really instructive to compare my comments with comments given to a couple of awardees who are acquaintances and also in social science disciplines.
-
On 3/18/2022 at 2:02 PM, DarkSideOfTheMoon said:
Just received this. So much for feedback:
Dear Applicant,
We received your inquiry regarding information about your application to the 2022 International Dissertation Research Fellowship (IDRF) competition. Unfortunately, we do not have comments available from the screener round.
Thank you again for your interest in the IDRF program.
Sincerely,
IDRF Program Team
I got the same reply. How strange!
-
@blinky Thanks for the excellent sleuthing! Good luck all.
-
On 2/23/2022 at 7:03 AM, Coffee Snob said:
In case folks don’t know: you can email IDRF asking for reviewers’ comments on your application. I did that last year & they responded quite fast.
This is really good to know! Thanks for telling us. I’m gonna email them for the comments.
-
Got the rejection email today, on 2/22 at 1:28pm. See you again next year.
-
-
No news on the portal or email for me either. The SSRC app was easily my least favorite - I reread my material and they are only slightly coherent and messy af.
-
On 2/10/2022 at 11:21 AM, GreenCholulaForLife said:
Lol, I have a feeling that SSRC has shut down without any notice to the parties that have stakes. So long Social Science Research Council. It was good to have you for all these years…
GreenCholulaForLife, I and 11 other people were selected earlier this week to participate in the fully funded AAS-SSRC Dissertation Workshop in Honolulu. SSRC is open and appears to have plenty of money. I was really confused by this speculation - do you know something that we don’t?
-
See below.
-
I'm a direct applicant this year. Have never applied before and so am not expecting much. I'm really interested in seeing how they score me.
-
I applied for the pre-doc fellowship this year. Not expecting much, but am interested in seeing how they score my application.
SSHRC Doctoral Fellowships & CGS D 2022-2023
in Waiting it Out
Posted
Just got off the waitlist from last year!!! I was number 6 on the waitlist.