I know that you are aiming at applying in the midwest, but your best chance at getting accepted to grad school is to apply as broadly as possible. If you are willing to relocate and apply to some of the less competitive programs in the south, and west as well then you will have better chances of getting in somewhere.
I would recommend you apply to a good number of less competitive programs in the midwest, and then add some like Eastern New Mexico, Idaho State, Wyoming in the west, and then schools like Montevallo, Louisiana Lafayette, Western Carolina in the south. Good luck!