I didn't say it before but this has been my first year applying to MFA program in photography and I'm not from the USA. This forum was so helpful that I have to say a general thanks!
@Rama
About Yale I think that they are the best photographers trainers ever but for people who want to be free to experiment, who want to take some risk and do something radically new and innovative it's the wrong place. I got this idea looking at the excellent work coming from their program of which the only lack, for me, is to be conformistic and I don't mean in a political way but in an aesthetical one. I had the same feeling about them to be a patriarchal institution and probably it is - which recalls so many traumas to my mind!.
But their aim is giving to the world superstar photographers and they're really good at doing it!
@Shutterbug
I'm currently studying at the SMFA and want to give you my point of view so that you can have more informations. I don't know which is your main medium and mine is photogaphy. But having a knowledge of most of the departments I can tell you that who does political works is just a little part of the faculty. In my department it's interesting the variety that with have. Every teacher seems to cover a particular kind of photography but on more than 8 photo teachers just two do conceptual/political work. My work is really very far from being political and not just they love it but promoted it around and wanting me to partecipate to some exhibitions that we had this year to represent the school. One thing that I'm gonna really miss of the SMFA and that I don't think I'll find anywhere else is the huge freedom and the help receive to find my own personal expression.
As for the 3 years, you're right...I don't like it too! But the third year is free and you are supposed to be working one you're thesis, so you can be in any place in the world.
Finally, I'm surprise to hear that about Laura McPhee. I had such a good impression when I met her that I can't imagine her to instill fear. She seems so sweet!