[2019 Waitlist Thread]

2 minutes ago, feralgrad said:

Ahh, I see. Well I don't know this specific program, but it may have to do with how the department handles POIs. Perhaps every POI makes an offer to 2+ students, and if that leaves space in the cohort, they start sending out more offers. At any rate, if they're being vague it's probably a matter of departmental policy; they may not be able to discuss precisely how the decisions process works. The important thing is that it sounds like you're probably high on the list (even if it's not a "sure thing").

I asked her in a straightforward way cuz I'm tired of being "not sure"?. She said I'm the #1 of the waiting list. And I even asked "is it still worth waiting? Is it possible for your program to make a 3rd offer?" She repeated "it's possible". Sounds a good news to me but I will definitely go for the job search now. 

I also encouraged all guys to give a call for the program if you are too worried. Get a talk in person to see what's going on there!

[2019 Waitlist Thread]

14 minutes ago, feralgrad said:

That sounds like a pretty standard waitlist procedure to me. I'd guess the program already accepted a 3rd applicant, but that applicant hasn't responded yet. If you're at the top of the waitlist your chances are decent, but applying to jobs is a smart move.

Thanks for your reply!! 

I just called the coordinator because I am too confused. She told me that the third offer has not been made. The decision of whether to make one more offer will depend on the number of the cohort of program (ph.d. in business). If there is more space for the whole cohort, this offer will be sent.

Well...whatever...it's something new to me.....?

[2019 Waitlist Thread]

I was notified that two offers had been accepted, but the program may be able to make a third but they will not know until April 15. Any one knows what's going on there? The coordinator told me it is possible, but I'm too worried and begin to apply for a job now.

[Fall 2019 Business PhD Applicants]

Hey All! 

I'm wondering if there is any difference between an interview with faculty and one with program's area coordinator. I had a phone interview with a program's phd area coordinator last week and we talked more about living expenses in NYC ( the university's in NYC) and my idea of moving to NYC. Does it mean a little bit higher of chance in admission when we're scheduled to interview with an area coordinator?

THX!

[Fall 2019 Business PhD Applicants]

13 hours ago, coffeefan said:

I applied at Questrom. Have not heard anything either

I see two  accepts in marketing in the result search. 

[Fall 2019 Business PhD Applicants]

27 minutes ago, phdmang said:

Congrats on the offer, though!  That's a huge accomplishment. 

Re: following up with schools - I've also heard that it's poor form, but I've had success with the "two-week rule": if you had a good conversation with someone and haven't heard back in ~2 weeks, I think a polite follow up is worthwhile.  I'll also say that I've had a few professors reach out to me after interviews to ask how "serious" I am about their program, so I think (tactfully) demonstrating commitment and interest is probably helpful.  

I couldn’t agree more. Follow-up sometimes is necessary after two weeks from the interview— what my experience tells me

[Post here to get your worries off your chest]

Worries: I just received a rejection from my dream program and it is the 3rd rejection i’ve got.

Excitement: Will graduate this May with an MBA degree. It’s always exciting to get something done! Also, I had a good performance in an interview with a very nice professor from a great university yesterday. Hope to receive an offer from this program!

[Fall 2019 Business PhD Applicants]

7 hours ago, aniston said:

Could I please ask which school interviewed you? I'm also waiting for the interviews and would be glad to know where I'm standing among other applicants.

Sure! Temple University (quant trek).

[Fall 2019 Business PhD Applicants]

Hey all! 

I’m applying for 12 schools (3 Canadians, 9 u.s) for their ph.d in marketing. So far I’ve received  an interview and still waiting for other 11. I hope we all good luck in the coming weeks!