Yeah exactly. It's like, there is no standard (no end) for that, and you don't know how good is good enough...
Oh...yeah, same, had Zoom calls with them before applying, and yeah, same, felt positive. Now I think those POIs were clever, super clever. There was ZERO cost for them to say: hey, I don't like you, don't waste application money on me. And I will be totally okay with that. But they all act so cunningly because obviously, the more people apply, the larger pool they can select from.
*Well they probably didn't want to break our faith & feelings (which they already did anyway)
Yeah, you are right. For some schools, the committee played the biggest role. I'm not from psychology (I'm from Computer Science), but I did have one school that the Prof never even saw my application and said it was rejected by the committee and never got passed to them.
But I feel that if you really care about me, you would be really worried when you didn't see my application and would talk to the committee to see what happened instead of waiting for me to ask you how my application is going (and tells me: sorry I can't control, I don't know, I never see it). It only means you don't really want to accept me in the first place. All those lovely words were simply you pretending to be nice. ? (this is probably a bit mean but, I was really really upset & a bit angry by some POIs)
Haha, thanks, hope you hear some good news too. Yeah...I guess I will re-apply as well, but honestly, there is only one summer left for the next application. I don't think it can make much difference? But my case is probably worse than yours since I've applied twice, and some schools only allows you to apply three times in your lifetime, so I need to use the last chance wisely.