confessionsofaphysicsgeek

Me too! I am so ready for this wait to be over!!!!!

It's gone now!

Looks like they announced maintenance on FastLane: "Due to maintenance, the following functions will be unavailable from 8:00 PM ET on 3/22 – 8:00 AM ET on 3/23: Research.gov No Cost Extension and PI Transfer N & Rs and Individual Banking. The following systems will also be unavailable from 10:00 PM ET on 3/22 – 8:00 AM ET on 3/23: Research.gov (including access to FastLane Proposal Review and Panelist Functions), FastLane Travel & Reimbursement, Graduate Research Fellowship Program, and NSF Public Access Repository (NSF-PAR). We apologize for any inconvenience. " What do we think this means? Results soon?

I had emailed them a week or two ago to ask why my date (12/1/2023) hadn't moved yet (it still has not changed). This is what they said "We are still reviewing the applications; you can expect to receive your status tentatively around April/May." So I wouldn't bank on hearing anything by the end of March...

My guess is that it’s this. My friend and I both applied for Materials Science and Engineering and neither of us have received any updates.

I haven't gotten any update since 12/1/2023... Still holding out that those updates mentioned were just people getting assigned to reviewers and hopefully mine will be updated soon. Really hope they don't just do desk rejections...

I am pretty sure reviews are probably just starting or haven’t even started yet. On the panelist tab it says: Panelist review approximately 20 applications via the DoD NDSEG FM Web Application in late January to early February. The application consists of the basic application-contact information along with a 3-page proposal, a 1-page personal statement, 3 references, transcripts, and GRE scores. My guess would be the December updates were after checking all the PII requirements.

I wouldn’t bank on anything from last years thread being a useful or accurate timeline. They have switched back to a different system they haven’t used in the past two application cycles. The email I got after I submitted my app said they will release results on March 31, 2024.

I did SMART as an undergrad. I wouldn’t recommend it for a PhD… google SMART scholarship forum and you’ll find a lot of info about people’s experiences.

Anyone hear back from emailing NDSEG? I saw NSF GRFP came out today. Good luck to all those who applied 🥰

I think we will probably hear by the end of next week! Results were all out by the 31st last year. I think I got my rejection on April 1 but it came late.

This is also what I have

I also have the 93.75% thing. Lol

Just got the update that I moved onto the second round today.

Just got another update: Jan 12

Mine says last edited December 25.

Mine says last edited December 7.

I meant to reference this comment in my last post. I don't know why NDSEG always has such a hard time communicating with applicants. I didn't even find out I was rejected last year until well after everyone else had received information.

I got this email. I am so confused. Everything I turned in was anonymized.

Mine says the same.

Just kidding: found it. VG/E E/E G/G - not awarded. Why did reviewer 3 come for me like this?

Am I dumb? How to I see the reviews?

According to past years data seems like it could really be like any time: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1LaF7o1oBPHAbVkxuHtAH7MeGDs7qsc_xZoB-Kijn4II/edit?usp=sharing From other comments here it seems like the emails with results get sent later.

I did this last week… gave me too much trauma. Never again.

Why did I open this thread I was having such a peaceful anxiety free weekend!