Jump to content

smartstrategy

Members
  • Posts

    54
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by smartstrategy

  1. 21 minutes ago, Relm said:

    I've said it before, I'll say it again. LOL @ methodology: "The rankings of Master of Fine Arts programs, completed in 2016, are based solely on the results of a peer assessment survey. Deans and other top academics at 229 Master of Fine Arts programs in art and design were surveyed in fall 2015 by Ipsos Public Affairs.

    "Survey recipients – one per school – were asked to rate the academic quality of fine arts programs on a scale of 1 (marginal) to 5 (outstanding). Scores for each school were totaled and divided by the number of respondents who rated that school. The response rate was 29 percent."

    But you're right -- it is really interesting. There are some big changes represented. I'm also fascinated by how some schools seem to stick in their rankings. Curious what people's biggest surprises are in that regard -- are there schools you think don't really deserve the rank they have (whether that's for being over- or underrated)? I'm also really interested in the psychological impact that these rankings have on perceived school prestige, but that's another matter altogether.

    I am glad you posted this.

    It is very important to note the response rate of only 29 percent!

    One could speculate that officials from a fair number of the top schools were among the 29 percent who responded;) No way of knowing. Did the respondents visit each school and look at the program in detail?!

    I think the list does contribute to perceived school prestige because many don't read the fine print like you did (onlly 29 percent response rate) and might think hey this is a printed publication that says that these are the best schools. Many of them are excellent. Other factors come into play. For example, a few years ago Rutgers was not well known. Then an online article was written about schools offering Best Bang for your Buck. Rutgers was on it. People on the forum wrote about large stipends. Now they get many more applicants due to the publicity boost. They seem to be a good school.

    However in my opinion I would take the rankings list with a grain of salt. Some are riding on a stellar reputation which might have existed years ago. The magazine is a marketing tool. They make money from publishing the info in this survey. People who don't know where to start in choosing a school might use the info when deciding where to apply because they don't have any other reliable source of info. Countless people on this forum apply to "the top ten" and they may well have decided based on that list.  I was accepted at several schools with  much higher "list" rankings than the one I decided to go to. I don't regret my choice.

    As always, my advice is go for funding unless you are able to pay yourself. Choose schools that offer funding where you think you might fit in. No school no matter how highly ranked guarantees your career path in the art world. It is very competitve out there.

     

  2. On 3/11/2016 at 4:25 PM, cpw0021 said:

    there's a thread for Skowhegan in the Waiting It Out forum.

    I just did VSC in February! :)

     

    FAWC had 705 applicants and only 46 are advancing to the final round. Notification received today. The application fee was 57 dollars.

    Good luck everyone.

  3. Hello all!

    i hope everyone is feel good about their applications.

    Thought/question:

    When applications ask of the applicant to disclose the other institutions that she/he is applying to, I find myself feeling uneasy and apprehensive. 

    Can anyone offer their thoughts on this topic? Must one be strictly honest when answering this question? If not, what strategies are recommended regarding selective disclosure?

    thank you all!

    Just leave it blank. They are fishing for information. None of their business:)

    If the school ultimately wants you they aren't going to reject you because you didn't answer that question. Decision will be based first and foremost on your portfolio.

    When/IF you get multiple offers from different schools, then you might tell them IF they ask as a negotiating tool.

     

  4. Yes you should ask in my opinion.

    Sometimes you can find info directly on the school website.

    Check out these threads as well on funding and offers to get possible info on the schools you are interested in also. I repost so that they are easier to find for newcomers to the forum.

    Fundng can also vary depending on how you rank once accepted ie some students get larger fellowships (no work required), some TA ships which pay less and require work, is health insurance paid for? Ask how many hours you would work ie 10 hours per week or 20 hours per week. Are international students funded as well? Can you receive in state tuition if you are out of state? A school may not offer that unless you ask.

    All the best to you and everyone else! This forum is a great resource.

  5. Thank you for posting some links to good material.

     

    Here are two crucial links that weren't posted regarding funded programs and offers received by accepted students.

     

    If you can't afford to pay and no subsidy at the school of your choice is offered or don't want to go into large debt check out schools that offer funding.

    International Students are often eligible but check of course to see what they might offer.

    The info is most likely still valid but check with the school directly. I think USC funding may have changed due to recent events.

     

    Also when you do get an offer, negotiate! Particularly if you have received several acceptances and offers.

    Thanks to everyone who has shared this excellent information and made it easier to find by posting in appropriate threads.

     

    This forum really starts to get busy around the end of December when applications are in by the way.

    You can send private messages to other members if you have an account. You won't get spam. This forum is an excellent source of information

     

    Good luck everyone!

     

    MFA programs in the USA with Excellent Funding (as of 2012)

     

    MFA arts 2015: FUNDING AND DECISIONS

  6. A good school will welcome diversity in their program.

    The work is most important.

    Committees are looking for potential students with promise.

     

    Ages can range from 21 to 56 years old. Perhaps even older.

     

    What is most important is your attitude and your ability to get along with and learn from others in the program without age being a factor.

     

    Some questions to consider:

     

    What can you offer the program?

    Will you be mature enough to show initiative and to create work regularly without being prompted by faculty and your peers?

    Will social activities take priority over making work?

    Are you ready for a very intense experience that will last several years?

     

    Can you take critical feedback well? Feedback that can be harsh?

    Can you be self-critical?

     

    Are you open to new ideas and viewpoints different from your own?

     

    Do you know why you want to go to grad school at this time?

    Are your goals realistic?

    Do you have a good understanding of Contemporary Art?

  7. Great read, Jerry Saltz rocks. I came across this article yesterday and it really helped to put things in perspective. I spent four years in a private art college and racked up over 80,000 in debt, even after a string of generous scholarships. I consider myself very lucky in that my parents have offered to pay for half. My undergraduate experience was invaluable, truly the best four years of my life, and well worth the investment. However, when it comes to the MFA, I refuse to pay for it. I simply can't afford to. I've spent the better part of the last 3 years researching graduate programs and I'm only applying to those that offer full rides, stipends, and work-study/ TA positions. These programs do exist, and although they don't all rank among the "US News World Report top ten", they're still fine programs with fantastic faculty, accomplished alumni, and opportunities abound. 100,000 for an MFA? Maybe if I could realistically make 100,000 a year upon graduation. Not very likely as an emerging visual artist.

     

    Also worth checking out is the article that Saltz referenced- 

     http://www.blouinartinfo.com/print/node/989814

    A very smart strategy!

     

    Here is a thread with a list of programs that offer funding.

    It has been posted elsewhere but I have reposted once again to make it easier for people to find as there is a ton of info on this forum to navigate.

     

  8. After a period of time reading certain posts and responses to certain posts by a variety of members I would like to share this resource which may or may not be of interest or help to some.

    It has helped me when I remember to use it!

     

    http://www.nonviolentcommunication.com/index.htm

     

    a further explanation of how it works

    http://www.ayahuasca-wasi.com/english/articles/NVC.pdf

     

    In my opinion, it is important to have the tools to communicate one's point effectively  in life, school, work, whatever....otherwise... well the point may be lost and even if you have great stuff to say, others might not hear it.

     

    :D :D :D

     

    Let's all have a big group hug, forget the "tit for tat", insults, return insults, give up the need to be right(eous), make peace with each other and wish each other well even if we may not always agree.

     

    There is too much anger in the world.

  9. Yeah... when I mentioned the acceptance rates of my top choice schools to my mother she had a very concerned look on her face.

    I am surprised to see that Cranbrook has such a high acceptance rate considering its reputation. I didn't want to move out there so I didn't research it much, do they not have more applicants because of cost?

    Does anyone know the rough acceptance rates for Rutgers and Bard? Probably also in the single digits I would assume.

    you can find lots of info on this site. do a search for the schools you are interested in.

    best of luck to you!

     

    rutgers

    http://www.petersons.com/graduate-schools/rutgers-the-state-university-of-new-jersey-new-brunswick-mason-gross-school-of-the-arts-program-in-visual-arts-000_10028628.aspx

     

    bard

    http://www.petersons.com/graduate-schools/bard-college-milton-avery-graduate-school-of-the-arts-000_10038831.aspx#GradDegreesAwards

  10. This discussion is important. I've experienced these things before and is why I left school once already. Its all on the school you go to, hands down. The top schools are the best because they have placement and connections. No connections means doing it on your own and I give sincere applause and best of wishes to those who want to go that route. Those choosing this route are the 'real artists' who don't subscribe to kissing ass and buying your way in. I love people and open spaces and creative dialogue, thats why I am wanting to go back - to hang with artists, make work and get shit crazy.

    Good points....Which schools do you personally consider to be the top schools currently?

  11. "OutWest

    For all you peeps trolling this Forum in the future...

    Though I am sure I have missed some (and please, if you got an offer not listed here, or you know of another, please add to it), these are the programs I found to have the best funding. In NO particular order:)]"

    Great information...

    You might want to put this information in a separate thread to make it easier for others to find in the future....

    Thanks for sharing it.

  12. ;) I have read that many people here have visited various schools to check out their programs....I'm outside the US so I'm not easily able to do that. I am trying to decide where to apply to next year for an MFA in Painting. (I only applied to one school this time and was rejected!). I would enjoy California but am open to any other suitable programmes where my kind of work might fit in. ..."neurotic or magical realism" apparently. I usually look at the faculty work and then grad student work but I'm having a challenge navigating through the options. Any suggestions of any kind would be most appreciated. Congratulations to everyone accepted. To others, remember it's all subjective, don't ever give up on your art! Thanks very much. Here is a link to some of my work , feel free to email me privately if you have any feedback on my stuff....i am tough!!! http://www.flickr.co...otos/olderdog/
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use