shortstack51

I just got waitlisted as well! Hope you dropping off the list improves my chances! I know someone on the board already plans on declining.

Sorry to those getting bad news it's making me quite anxious! At first I wanted an e-mail from the program today, but now I don't because so far there have only been rejections

I'm sorry to hear that I still haven't heard anything...Not sure if they're doing rejections in waves? Also not sure if they're done accepting people. I'm trying not to get my hopes up.

I suppose I could be wrong, or the details were fuzzy. I'm sure it also changes year to year. I had asked him to check (he was my professor at the time) what my relative chances would be.

As far as I know, Yale doesn't usually have more than 5 spots open (was told this by former Yale adcomm person who asked Yale last year). Not sure if that's changed though- it's always hard to predict.

Oh great! That's great to know. They weren't offering funding to everyone last year. Crossing my fingers harder now...

There are definitely more coming! CUNY usually admits a decent amount of students, though funding is the big question. They didn't even provide funding a few years ago if I remember correctly, but they have certainly made a lot of changes to their program. I don't think they offer it to many, though. I hope we both hear good news as well!

There have been acceptances dribbling in since Friday--three in total I think. Congrats to those who got accepted! I keep checking my e-mail nervously since I saw the first one pop up on Friday or Saturday.

I have a love-hate relationship. I like it a lot better now that I live in a small city outside of the city, but it still gives me the grumps when I commute in for work on the train. It always smells like pee and crap and garbage. But there's a lot to love. I'll be happy enough living here again. I just get tired of hearing gunshots. It doesn't happen that often since I moved (once a month?), but it's definitely not fun when it does. I also grew up in the mountains, so I'm certainly biased. These CUNY acceptances are making me nuts! I'll go check the CUNY thread I guess.

Sorry if this is a dumb question, but what does 2-2, 2-1, etc. mean? Right now I TA for a course as a part time job ("TA" in a loose sense--I actually just grade the papers). I grade 30 3 page papers a week. It's a bit rough because I also work as a tutor on campus and in the admin. Add a full course load on top of that... I'm actually looking forward to whatever I get from a PhD program because at least it won't be 30-40 hours a week (what I'm doing now--well, what I'm doing when we aren't canceled due to snow)! I know my school's PhD program and a couple of others put grad students into the writing center to start and then have you take pedagogy courses. That seems pretty logical to me.

Glad I'm in good company! I'm not really sure if I'll actually do that, but it's one of my back up options. My fiancee has family in the Netherlands, so we have people to stay with until we get on our feet over there. And I've never been out of the country before. If I recall, you and I also had a deal earlier where we would help each other improve our apps if we decide to apply again if all doesn't work out--I might also take you up on that!

Good luck!! I have 7 left, which is a nice cushion, but two of those are Princeton and Harvard (which I definitely won't get into), and one is U of Washington, which is a reach...and, well, everywhere feels like a reach right now, even my own school's program! Sending good vibes your way. I am seriously considering working for a year and then moving away (possibly internationally) once all is said and done if I don't get in. If my own program rejects me, clearly something is wrong, haha. Someone said CUNY Grad is supposed to get back to us tomorrow and the rest of the week. Crossing my fingers! (Although I would like to get accepted to somewhere outside of NYC--I'm kind of sick of living here...but beggars can't be choosers I suppose and I do love the programs here)

Haha, I suppose I think of Boston as relatively cheap because I live in NYC currently where you're lucky to find anything decent for less than $1600/month

Yes, I have the same problem. It says I paid for my application on the 15th but then it says it wasn't created until the 17th, which is weird. I am also worried because they wanted you to mail transcripts in one envelope with a very specific formatting on the front, but I sent both of mine to straight from my school. I have no idea if that will impact me negatively. Congrats on Carnegie Mellon!! I'm happy to hear that! Where else have you applied and are still waiting to hear back from? I'm sure you will hear more good news from MA programs.

Ugh that's a really stressful situation! I'm so sorry. It's one of 3 PhD programs I really feel I have a shot at now. I do have to say I ended up doing an MA my first time and it really helped me grow a lot. My undergrad advisors said that loans just kind of come with our field most of the time. What schools would you possibly be doing an MA at, if you don't mind my asking? (Curious to see if it's mine- I try not to advertise where I am currently to retain at least some level of anonymity!)

I should add that while I'm not very familiar with Boston, it is the cleanest and easiest city to get around that I've visited, if we're talking about living situations. Costs aren't horrible, especially of you take the commuter rail in from an outside town. And it's a very historic city, so a lot of the apartments are in old houses and buildings, if you're into that. Lots to do of course, etc etc, it's right on the ocean, all that good stuff. I applied to a few schools in Boston, but it doesn't look like I'm getting in, so I'm jealous you'll have the chance to live there!

Nevermind- I was referring to a posting from several days ago. I have no idea what's going on with the most recent one.

Someone in another thread said they contacted the department who said they would make decisions Tuesday. Either the post was a fake or they were in an informal e-mail conversation with someone at CUNY already--that's all I can come up with.

Seconded- I lived in the next town over for 3 months. There's not much to rent in the first place and the cost of living on Long Island is high. You will definitely need a car there as well. The village of Stony Brook is a cute little northeastern town with a park, and there are some things to do. It's actually one of the only hilly areas on LI so it isn't as flat and boring as the rest of it. For fun, a lot of LI people usually go into the city or go upstate, both of which are a hike from Stony Brook (1 hr 45 mins by train to the city). There are also the LI beaches, of course. Also, Port Jefferson (with the ferry to CT) is nearby. There are a lot of shops/bars there and a lot of young folks hang out there. I've heard good things about the program at Stony Brook itself. Just be prepared for a lot of strip malls. Also, traffic is always awful once you get out of the villages/small towns. TL;DR- if you don't mind small towns and suburbia and high cost, and you like the visit, go for it. But it can certainly feel soul sucking to live on LI. My fiancee's mother desperately wanted me to apply to Stony Brook so we could possibly move back. I didn't because I just can't resign myself to living there.

This. I was in a small, education-focused cohort as an undergrad and being in an MA, where class sizes are 8 people and half of those people are PhD students, has made me a lot more versatile as a scholar.

Congrats to everyone on the acceptances! what a great day for you!!

Good luck!! And try not to stress! When universities start calling, it usually takes a couple of days because it takes more organizing on the adcomm's end.

Ack!! Now CUNY got back to someone! It was an informal e-mail I guess, but yikes. I'm so tense. Womp.

Yes definitely! That would be a big help for me. I'm hoping that my current school will at least take me, but it's top 50 so it's not necessarily a guarantee. I also feel I only have 4 schools left that I have a decent shot at, and 2 (including my current program) don't send out responses until mid-March. Yikes.

7, how about you? 3 of those are super reach schools for me so I'm nervous.