Funding versus Research Interest

[TongueTwist]

I have two offers I'm torn between. 

Offer 1: slightly better reputation with mentor whose research interests align better with mine.  Tuition remission and $18k stipend as an RA with option to renew yearly for up to 4 years; more remote location, no "guarantee" on amount of future years of support--year to year budget

Offer 2: slightly worse reputation (as compared to offer 1) in my field with a mentor with research interests further outside of mine.  Tuition remission and $25k fellowship (no work required) for the first year with option to renew annually as an RA (more likely guaranteed funding for up to 4 years than offer 1); more urban location, would allow my spouse better options for finding work.

What are your all's thoughts?

Thanks!

Edited April 1, 2017 by TongueTwist
spelling