Jump to content

psm1580b

Members
  • Posts

    187
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Reputation Activity

  1. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from Davidspring in Declining 2016   
    I feel the same about Indiana and Western.
  2. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from Siegfried42 in 2016 Rejection/Plan B Thread   
    Here's a little perspective:
      I applied to Stanford last year, as well as several other top programs, and I learned from their rejection letter that they had over 400 applicants last year. 400. Given that those were PhD applicants to Stanford it's reasonable to assume that the top 80 or so were objectively indistinguishable from each other. Even if they can only accept 4 or so new students, that's only a 5% chance that you reasonably have of getting picked. You're not being shut out of other places because of anything wrong with your application, you're getting shut out because there are hundreds of other applicants who are at least as objectively good as you. It's a stats game, nothing more. Many people who are getting multiple acceptances have been applying for more than one year--they've had the extra time to really work on focusing their statements and working on reaching out to professors. 
    Congratulations, you got into Harvard. That's an incredible achievement.
    Now start treating that acceptance with the respect it deserves, or decline, and let someone else do so. 
  3. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from MentalEngineer in Venting Thread   
    Everything about that makes me mad. 
  4. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from FILOS in 2016 Rejection/Plan B Thread   
    Here's a little perspective:
      I applied to Stanford last year, as well as several other top programs, and I learned from their rejection letter that they had over 400 applicants last year. 400. Given that those were PhD applicants to Stanford it's reasonable to assume that the top 80 or so were objectively indistinguishable from each other. Even if they can only accept 4 or so new students, that's only a 5% chance that you reasonably have of getting picked. You're not being shut out of other places because of anything wrong with your application, you're getting shut out because there are hundreds of other applicants who are at least as objectively good as you. It's a stats game, nothing more. Many people who are getting multiple acceptances have been applying for more than one year--they've had the extra time to really work on focusing their statements and working on reaching out to professors. 
    Congratulations, you got into Harvard. That's an incredible achievement.
    Now start treating that acceptance with the respect it deserves, or decline, and let someone else do so. 
  5. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from isostheneia in 2016 Waitlist Thread   
    Waitlisted at Western!!!
    Oh god I want this so bad.... 
    This came via email letting me know that, sadly, they're only able to fund very few international students, but I'm on their waitlist so we'll see.
  6. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from Dialectica in 2016 Waitlist Thread   
    I started the Declining 2016 thread. I couldn't wait. 
  7. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from 759 in 2016 Waitlist Thread   
    I started the Declining 2016 thread. I couldn't wait. 
  8. Upvote
    psm1580b reacted to MickeyRay in Venting Thread   
    Actually, Vanderbilt is the best place for women hands down. From what I've heard. 
  9. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from bechkafish in Venting Thread   
    I was, rather hilariously, emailed and told of my WL at a Canadian school the morning after the GOP debate. Coincidence? or pity?
  10. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from 759 in Declining 2016   
    This thread is a place for people (like me) to gain small amounts of hope from hearing which school offers people (like you) are going to decline. So, if you've been offered admission (or put on a WL) and have declined or intend to decline, you're welcome and encouraged to say so here. 
    Thanks! 
     
    (I did totally steal this idea from someone else, but seeing as it hasn't happened yet--I thought I'd get the ball rolling)
     

  11. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from dgswaim in 2016 Waitlist Thread   
    Waitlisted at Western!!!
    Oh god I want this so bad.... 
    This came via email letting me know that, sadly, they're only able to fund very few international students, but I'm on their waitlist so we'll see.
  12. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from 502845824 in Declining 2016   
    No, that's perfect. This should be some good information for those keeping data on admissions and waitlists. 
  13. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from Abendstern in Declining 2016   
    No, that's perfect. This should be some good information for those keeping data on admissions and waitlists. 
  14. Upvote
    psm1580b reacted to MVSCZAR in Venting Thread   
    Good point. I should probably tell Toronto I'm a commie so they can get me off of that waitlist. 
  15. Upvote
    psm1580b reacted to Chrysippus'Doge in 2016 Rejection/Plan B Thread   
    Forgot that today was Friday, accidentally ate meat at dinner. Accordingly, there was an e-mail from Notre Dame waiting for me at home telling me I was a bad Catholic, God was displeased, and so I couldn't be in their program. Ah well. 
    Come on UConn. 
  16. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from Abendstern in Declining 2016   
    This thread is a place for people (like me) to gain small amounts of hope from hearing which school offers people (like you) are going to decline. So, if you've been offered admission (or put on a WL) and have declined or intend to decline, you're welcome and encouraged to say so here. 
    Thanks! 
     
    (I did totally steal this idea from someone else, but seeing as it hasn't happened yet--I thought I'd get the ball rolling)
     

  17. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from bechkafish in Declining 2016   
    This thread is a place for people (like me) to gain small amounts of hope from hearing which school offers people (like you) are going to decline. So, if you've been offered admission (or put on a WL) and have declined or intend to decline, you're welcome and encouraged to say so here. 
    Thanks! 
     
    (I did totally steal this idea from someone else, but seeing as it hasn't happened yet--I thought I'd get the ball rolling)
     

  18. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from Dialectica in Declining 2016   
    This thread is a place for people (like me) to gain small amounts of hope from hearing which school offers people (like you) are going to decline. So, if you've been offered admission (or put on a WL) and have declined or intend to decline, you're welcome and encouraged to say so here. 
    Thanks! 
     
    (I did totally steal this idea from someone else, but seeing as it hasn't happened yet--I thought I'd get the ball rolling)
     

  19. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from MVSCZAR in 2016 Waitlist Thread   
    Waitlisted at Western!!!
    Oh god I want this so bad.... 
    This came via email letting me know that, sadly, they're only able to fund very few international students, but I'm on their waitlist so we'll see.
  20. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from torpedofish in Venting Thread   
    It is hard to keep hopes up, for sure. Right now, I only have one WL. That's it. Out of 10 schools, one so far has said, "Eh, you may not be that bad, but lets not make any commitment yet..." 
    So basically, I feel as happy as the guy who proposed to his partner on bended knee and hears them respond, "Eh, you may not be that bad, but lets not make any commitments yet..." 
  21. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from sbroccoli in Venting Thread   
    It is hard to keep hopes up, for sure. Right now, I only have one WL. That's it. Out of 10 schools, one so far has said, "Eh, you may not be that bad, but lets not make any commitment yet..." 
    So basically, I feel as happy as the guy who proposed to his partner on bended knee and hears them respond, "Eh, you may not be that bad, but lets not make any commitments yet..." 
  22. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from oldmanPhDStudent in Venting Thread   
    It is hard to keep hopes up, for sure. Right now, I only have one WL. That's it. Out of 10 schools, one so far has said, "Eh, you may not be that bad, but lets not make any commitment yet..." 
    So basically, I feel as happy as the guy who proposed to his partner on bended knee and hears them respond, "Eh, you may not be that bad, but lets not make any commitments yet..." 
  23. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from Hadeel in 2016 Acceptance Thread   
    Congratulations ND admits! 
    I knew I shouldn't have told them I was a Buddhist...
  24. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from DontGetMeSartred in 2016 Acceptance Thread   
    Congratulations ND admits! 
    I knew I shouldn't have told them I was a Buddhist...
  25. Upvote
    psm1580b got a reaction from blondeambition in 2016 Waitlist Thread   
    If anyone, like me, needs a little good news, I took a look back at some prior results for Indiana HPS for 2015 and noticed that the number of posted WL's was equal to the number of acceptances (+1 who was accepted off WL and declined). So, there's a little bit of positive news for those of us who were WL'd...
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use