Thanks Zissou for your kind words! I will definitely apply again and see what happens, it was comforting to here that at least one of the current MFAs had interviewed twice before she got in so there's still a chance.
Lavendercloud: Thank you also for the encouragement. It's amazing how helpful someone else's perspective can be. Here is the list of schools I applied to if you're interested. As you can see I applied to a lot and got a lot of rejection despite the elusive Yale interview. It's amazing how subjective the whole process is. I didn't apply to Ohio but I'm looking into it now that you've said such wonderful things about your experience with them. I hope you won't be a stranger to this forum after you go off to grad school. I'd love to hear more about what it's like there as a student.
Yale: Interview, Rejected
Columbia: Interview, Waitlisted
NYU: Rejected
Michener: Rejected
Iowa: Rejected
Brown: Rejected
UT Austin: No response but I know offers went out so expecting rejection any day
Juilliard: No response