About two weeks ago, I e-mailed my prospective LOR writers. My first two responded immediately, but the third has been mostly unresponsive. SO, I've pretty much decided I need to find someone else to write my third letter. Here's an outline of my first two letter writers:
#1 PI of the lab in which I am lab manager. Been working for him for over a year. Never had him as a professor.
#2 Professor that I had my senior year for a research methods course. Been working for her since then as a part-time research assistant (almost two years now).
So those two are a sure thing, and I know they will both write great letters. Here are the options for my third...
- Professor I did research with over a year ago. It was essentially a data entry type position. Haven't spoken to her since, but she is very nice. Letter would likely be generic, but likely positive.
- Former grad student from the lab in which I am lab manager. She just left to take an assistant Prof position. Helped her with her dissertation. She would write an awesome letter, BUT would it be weird to have a (former) grad student write a LOR? Even if she is a Professor now? Also slightly concerned that she wouldn't have the time, seeing as this is her first semester teaching/ at a new University.
- I could keep trying to contact my original #3. I had her for two classes relevant to my field, and I know she would write a good letter. The problem is that she is at another school now, and has been unresponsive by e-mail. I'm just worried that even if I do get a hold of her, she might agree to write the letter but then again be unresponsive.
What should I do?