For anyone waiting on UMass-I sent an email to inquire about a possible decision timeline and found out I was rejected. I'm assuming those who were accepted were already notified. I asked if I could be considered for the MA program, which will have decisions go out by the end of the week.
Edit: I just found out they won't be offering funding to their MA students and have withdrawn my app.
It's still early. I'd say wait and see if you get off the waitlist before making any decisions. Personally, I'd go with the for sure since who knows what could happen in the next application cycle. On the other hand, if you're doing something in the next couple of months that will help your application, then I guess you can reapply and see what happens.
If any of the Rutgers Waitlist people are here, do you mind sharing how you were notified and your field? Trying to figure out if I should prepare for the rejection.
I e-mailed mine and responded to the e-mail from DGS. Idk if it will make any difference but I thought it wise to thank them and continue to emphasize my interest in the program.
Congratulations! If you are comfortable financially with a lower stipend vs cost of living, then I would go with School #2. You want a program with a good track history going in. I've been the guinea pig for programs before and its rough.